A federal judge ruled Cabell County and Huntington cannot hold the nation’s three largest drug distributors liable for the opioid crisis that devastated their communities, Mountain State Spotlight reported.
Senior U.S. District Judge David A. Faber found the municipalities failed to prove AmerisourceBergen, Cardinal Health and McKesson created a public nuisance by shipping massive quantities of painkillers to the region. The decision, issued Nov. 18, rejects a $2.5 billion abatement plan sought by the city and county to address addiction, foster care and crime costs tied to the epidemic.
“How can it be unreasonable for a wholesale distributor of opioids to fulfill bulk orders for opioids that are used to fill prescriptions written by doctors in good faith?” Faber wrote in his order.
The ruling marks the second time Faber has sided with the distributors. His 2022 decision was appealed to the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which certified a question to the West Virginia Supreme Court asking whether public nuisance law applied.
When the state high court declined to answer, the 4th Circuit ruled the law could apply broadly and returned the case to Faber for a new evaluation. He reached the same conclusion.
Volume of shipments not enough for liability
Faber determined the sheer volume of pills distributed — roughly 6,000 overdose deaths occurred statewide from 2001 through 2015, according to West Virginia health officials cited by WCHS-TV — did not by itself establish the distributors acted unreasonably. The evidence showed no proof the companies sent drugs to pill mills, knew pills were being diverted, or knew how many pills “should” have been sent to the area, Mountain State Spotlight reported.
“Their theory of the case was essentially that the volume of opioids distributed was in and of itself unreasonable,” Faber wrote.

The judge found doctors’ prescribing decisions, pharmacists’ dispensing and subsequent diversion to illegal use were “effective intervening causes beyond the control of defendants,” according to the ruling cited by WCHS-TV.
Judge outlines narrower remedy
While ruling for the distributors, Faber said a more appropriate remedy would be about $330 million of the proposed $2.5 billion plan, Mountain State Spotlight reported. He wrote that only one component of the municipalities’ proposal — drug take-back and safe storage programs — directly targeted the alleged wrongful conduct of oversupply.
Funds would need to be strictly focused on help for people with addiction, not prevention or other areas of the 15-year plan, Faber wrote.
Appeal planned
Paul Farrell, a lawyer for the city and county, said he will appeal the decision.
The distributors “played an essential role in distributing prescription opioids and other medicines to pharmacies, hospitals and other licensed dispensers so that they are ultimately available to patients on a timely basis,” Faber wrote in the order quoted by WCHS-TV.
Huntington, often called the epicenter of the opioid epidemic, saw overdose rates higher than the state average, which itself exceeded the national average, according to WCHS-TV. Substance abuse drove increases in foster care placements, crime and infectious diseases, the station reported.
Cabell County seeks $2.5 billion opioid abatement plan
Whether the “Big Three” distributors could be held liable under West Virginia public nuisance law for fulfilling large prescription orders that were later diverted to illegal use.
Cabell County and Huntington were seeking $2.5 billion for a 15-year plan to address the opioid epidemic’s damage. The municipalities requested a $2.5 billion, 15-year abatement plan to address epidemic-related costs including addiction treatment, foster care and law enforcement.
Faber indicated about $330 million would be appropriate, limited strictly to addiction treatment and drug take-back programs.
Has this case been decided before?
Yes. Faber ruled for the distributors in 2022. The 4th Circuit vacated that ruling and sent it back after determining public nuisance law could apply.
Born in Charleston in 1942, David A. Faber earned a Ph.D. in history from the University of Cambridge in 2014, decades after his Yale Law School degree. He served as U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia from 1981 to 1986 before President George H.W. Bush appointed him to the federal bench in 1991.
What happens next?
Paul Farrell, counsel for the plaintiffs, said an appeal will be filed.
Worth a look
- Train of Atlantic Disturbances to Bring Heavy Rain, Snow Down to 1,000m in Alps
- AFP Fact Check: AI Video Fabricated Showing Fazlur Rehman Embracing Woman
- 2025 ACS Data Show Arizona Families Struggle Before Federal Cuts (news-usa.today)
- Former Penn State Student Indicted on Federal Cocaine Trafficking Charges (archyworldys.com)