Fiorentina vs. Inter: Handball Penalty Decision Upheld by Italian Referees Association
The Italian Referees Association (AIA) has defended the decision not to award Fiorentina a penalty during their 1-1 draw with Inter Milan on March 22, 2026, despite debate surrounding a potential handball by Fiorentina defender Marin Pongracic. The incident occurred nine minutes into the Serie A match at the Stadio Artemio Franchi, with Inter already leading 1-0.
The Incident and Initial Reactions
The ball struck Pongracic’s arm, prompting appeals for a penalty. Yet, both the on-field referee and VAR officials dismissed the claims. Following the match, Inter President Beppe Marotta expressed his belief that several pundits considered the incident a clear penalty, calling for greater consistency in refereeing decisions.
AIA’s Explanation
Mauro Tonolini, representing the AIA, clarified the decision on DAZN’s Open VAR program. He stated that the referee had a clear view of the play and correctly assessed the situation. According to Tonolini, the ball bounced in front of Pongracic as he attempted a heel touch, and his arm was in a natural position during the movement. A handball penalty was not warranted.
VAR Confirmation
Audio from the VAR booth, featuring Fabio Maresca and Davide Massa, further supported the on-field decision. Maresca and Massa agreed that Pongracic attempted to pull his arm away from the ball, and the ball’s trajectory changed due to the bounce, not a deliberate handball. They concluded that the dynamics of the play did not justify awarding a penalty.
Expert Opinions
DAZN pundit Luca Marelli immediately agreed with the no-penalty call. However, other observers noted that similar handball incidents have resulted in penalties earlier in the season, highlighting the need for clearer guidelines regarding handball interpretations.
Other Weekend Decisions
The AIA also confirmed the correctness of two other penalty decisions made during the same weekend of Serie A matches: a penalty awarded to Juventus for a handling offense by Jay Idzes, and a penalty awarded to Torino after a foul by Milan defender Strahinja Pavlovic on Giovanni Simeone.
Looking Ahead
The decision in the Fiorentina-Inter match continues to spark debate, emphasizing the ongoing challenges in interpreting handball rules and the importance of consistent application by referees. The AIA’s backing of the decision aims to provide clarity and maintain confidence in the officiating process as the Scudetto race intensifies.
Keep reading