Four First Nations in Quebec—Abitibiwinni, Lac-Simon, Kitcisakik, and Kitigan Zibi—are accusing Hydro-Québec of unequal treatment regarding hydroelectric development negotiations, pointing to a stark contrast in how the state-owned utility engages with different Indigenous communities.
According to a joint press release issued by the Anishinabeg leadership, the communities signed an agreement in principle with the Quebec government on July 15, 2024, aimed at settling historical grievances caused by hydroelectric infrastructure on their traditional territories. However, negotiations were unilaterally suspended by Hydro-Québec in July 2026 due to financial disagreements.
Unequal Treatment Alleged in Hydroelectric Talks
Abitibiwinni First Nation Chief Chantal Kistabish stated that Hydro-Québec’s decision to halt discussions with the Anishinabeg contrasts sharply with the utility’s willingness to maintain dialogue in other files when it deems continued talks economically advantageous.
While avoiding direct mention of the Pessamit First Nation—whose members recently rejected an agreement that would have generated up to $7 billion over 50 years—the leaders criticized a system of differential treatment based on the commercial energy potential of specific traditional territories.
Kitigan Zibi Anishinabeg Chief Jean-Guy Whiteduck expressed deep concern via press release that Hydro-Québec reserves its dialogue efforts for communities whose lands hold strategic value for new energy projects. He noted that communities bearing historical impacts but offering less short-term energy potential are sidelined from serious engagement.
Constitutional Obligations and Demand for Equity
Kitcisakik Chief Édouard Brazeau emphasized that Indigenous rights should not depend on the number of additional megawatts a community can supply to the grid. Brazeau stated that the Crown’s constitutional obligations, along with the duty to consult and act honorably toward Indigenous peoples, apply equally to all First Nations without distinction.
The leadership is calling on both the Quebec government and Hydro-Québec to fulfill their respective roles and apply consistent principles of fairness across all First Nations.
Path Forward and Long-Term Benefits
Chief Jean-Guy Whiteduck confirmed that the Anishinabeg First Nations remain open to returning to the negotiation table, provided the terms ensure long-term equity.
“We never closed that door, but it has to be fair today and long term,” Whiteduck said in an interview. Pointing to past deals such as those with the Cree Nation, he argued that ongoing revenues generated by existing dams require continuous long-term benefits for First Nations rather than one-sided arrangements. “If it’s continuous for Quebec, it must be continuous for the First Nations, too,” he insisted.
At the time of publication, representatives from Hydro-Québec had not yet provided a comment on the allegations.
Related reading