International Edition
Latest News
World

Five European Countries Plan Rwanda Return Hub; Switzerland May Join If Viable

Five European countries announced on November 16 a plan to send rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda starting in 2027, a move Switzerland said it would consider joining if the project proves viable. Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the…

Five European Countries Plan Rwanda Return Hub; Switzerland May Join If Viable

Five European countries announced on November 16 a plan to send rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda starting in 2027, a move Switzerland said it would consider joining if the project proves viable.

Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands unveiled the “return hub” proposal at the Vienna Migration Conference, aiming to relieve pressure on EU borders by transferring people who have exhausted all legal avenues to remain in Europe. The hub would hold around 100 people in a pilot phase, with the first transfers expected in 2027.

“If the project proves to be successful, sustainable and feasible whilst complying with all legal requirements, Switzerland will consider the possibility of participating in it,” a Swiss justice ministry spokesperson told Keystone-ATS.

The Swiss Senate backed a motion last summer calling for the government to join European return hubs, and a House of Representatives committee recommended approval. Parliament still must pass implementing legislation, a process the government estimates will take roughly two years.

The plan revives a concept the United Kingdom pursued until Prime Minister Keir Starmer scrapped it in 2024, calling the British scheme “dead and buried before it started.” The European version differs: only people whose asylum claims have been finally rejected would be sent to Rwanda, not applicants whose cases are still pending.

Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said arrivals would receive a “second chance” to return home voluntarily, integrate in Rwanda or relocate to another country where they have legal rights. “There will be an independent monitoring mechanism” and cooperation with the UN refugee agency, Biruta told reporters in Vienna.

Human rights groups dispute those assurances. Forty-seven aid, trade union and rights organisations urged the five countries to abandon the plan, warning it could become a “black hole for human rights” with insufficient legal safeguards and no monitoring system to prevent abuse.

“Paying Kigali to host a deportation program would not only cause suffering and harm to those deported, it would finance and provide political leverage to a government responsible for serious human rights abuses at home and abroad,” Clémentine de Montjoye, senior researcher in Human Rights Watch’s Africa division, said.

Amnesty International Austria’s asylum and migration expert Aimée Stuflesser called the deal “disgraceful” and said sending people to a country they have never been to is “irresponsible.”

Olivia Sundberg, Amnesty’s EU advocate on migration and asylum, told euronews the announcement leaves critical gaps: “We don’t know how much it will cost; we don’t know what Rwanda has been offered in exchange; we don’t know what guarantees exist for people; we don’t know how the courts will intervene; we don’t know what protections will be in place; and we don’t know who’s legally responsible if something goes wrong.”

The European plan rests on the EU Return Regulation, adopted by the Council of the European Union in June 2026, which permits member states to establish return hubs outside the EU in countries that respect international human rights law. Unaccompanied minors are excluded from transfers.

Five European Countries Plan Rwanda Return Hub; Switzerland May Join If Viable
Photo: The Conversation

Critics point to Rwanda’s record. President Paul Kagame was re-elected in 2024 with 99 percent of the vote, and UN experts say Rwanda exercises significant control over the M23 rebels in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, who are accused of war crimes including sexual violence.

Germany reduced aid to Rwanda in 2024 over its role in that conflict. The UK Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that Rwanda was not a safe third country for asylum seekers, a finding the European coalition says its narrower design avoids.

France has distanced itself from the initiative. President Emmanuel Macron said in 2023: “I have never seen a return hub in a third country operate.” Italy’s parallel arrangement with Albania, which converted the Gjadër centre into a return hub in 2025, has drawn heavy criticism from Italian courts and rights groups; Albania has signalled the deal may not survive past 2030, when it expects to join the EU.

Key details remain unresolved. The five countries have not disclosed the project’s cost, the total capacity beyond the pilot, how responsibilities will be shared with Rwanda, or the legal framework for monitoring and accountability. A final agreement is expected within months, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said in Vienna.

What the Rwanda return hub would do

The hub would accept only people whose asylum applications have been finally rejected and who cannot be returned to their home countries because those countries refuse cooperation.

They would not be detained as prisoners; Rwandan officials say they could live and work in Rwanda while arrangements are made for voluntary return, local integration or relocation to a third country where they have rights. The pilot phase aims to accommodate roughly 100 people at a time.

Rwanda, a landlocked East African nation of 26,338 square kilometres bordered by Uganda, Tanzania, Burundi and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, is among the world’s most densely populated countries with 578 people per square kilometre. Its capital, Kigali, sits at 1,567 metres above sea level in the centre of the country.

After gaining independence in 1962 following Belgian colonial rule and a Hutu-led revolution, the country was devastated by the 1994 genocide against the Tutsi, which ended with the Rwandan Patriotic Front’s military victory. The RPF has governed since, with Paul Kagame as president since 2000.

Five EU countries pursue Rwanda return hub plan amid human rights concerns — Al Jazeera English

How it differs from the UK scheme

Feature UK–Rwanda plan (2022–2024) EU five-country plan (announced 2026)
Who is transferred Asylum seekers arriving irregularly, before claims decided Only people with final rejected claims and exhausted appeals
Asylum processing Outsourced to Rwanda Completed in EU before transfer
Legal basis Bilateral treaty EU Return Regulation (June 2026)
Status Scrapped by Starmer government July 2024 Under negotiation; first transfers targeted for 2027

Open questions

  • Cost and funding: No figure has been published.
  • Legal responsibility: Unclear whether the sending state, Rwanda, or both bear liability for rights violations.
  • Monitoring mechanism: Rwanda promises an independent body and UNHCR cooperation; no terms or mandate have been released.
  • Capacity beyond pilot: The five countries have not said how many people they ultimately intend to transfer.
  • Swiss participation: Parliament must still pass legislation; the government has roughly two years to align Swiss law with the EU Return Regulation.

“A final agreement is expected within months,” Stocker said in Vienna.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.