Fossil trawler bycatch reveals a killer-whale ancestor the size of the largest modern males hunted large prey in the North Sea more than two million years ago.
The discovery pushes the origin of macroraptorial feeding — the grip-and-tear strategy used by today’s Antarctic Type A orcas to take seals and baleen whales — back to the Gelasian stage of the Early Pleistocene, roughly 2.6 to 2.1 million years ago.
Until now, the only recognized fossil species, Orcinus citoniensis from Pliocene Italy, measured just 3.5 metres and likely ate fish. The new material, assigned to Orcinus sp., shows the lineage achieved apex-predator size and anatomy far earlier than genomic estimates of modern ecotype divergence in the Middle Pleistocene suggested.
Researchers from the Natural History Museum Rotterdam, the Geological Survey of the Netherlands, the University of Pisa and Arcadis Nederland examined five fragmentary fossils — two partial skulls, a mandible fragment and two atlas-axis complexes — recovered as bycatch by commercial trawlers working the Noordhinder and Outer Gabbard grounds about 100 kilometres west of Rotterdam.
Regression analyses based on living Orcinus orca and 3-D model comparisons yield a body-length estimate of 7.2 to 7.7 metres, matching the largest extant males. Palynological dating of dinoflagellate cysts in sediment still adhering to one cranium constrained the age to the Gelasian.
“Killer whales are highly social animals living and hunting almost exclusively in pods, displaying a wide range of feeding strategies,” lead author Hidde Bakker and colleagues wrote in the study. “Populations with a macropredatory diet deploy a grip-and-tear technique similar to some species of shark, which is a rare behavior among toothed whales.”

The mandible bears large, deep and widely separated alveoli, while the cervical vertebrae show deeply excavated condylar fossae allowing a wide range of head movement — traits the team links to macroraptorial capability.
“Orcinus sp. represents the largest Pleistocene delphinid yet documented and provides the earliest known evidence for the emergence of macroraptorial predation within Delphinidae, substantially predating the Middle Pleistocene divergence of modern killer whale ecotypes inferred from genomic data,” the authors concluded.
The paper was published on 10 November 2026 in PeerJ (doi: 10.7717/peerj.21890). The authors caution that the fossils do not reveal precisely which animals the ancient orca ate, although other large marine mammals, including dolphins and baleen whales, inhabited the North Sea at the time.
Why the North Sea fossils matter
The find demonstrates that the killer whale’s role as an apex predator was established more than two million years ago, far earlier than genetic evidence alone had indicated.
“By demonstrating that this feeding strategy was established more than two million years ago, our results underscore both the long-term stability of apex predation in marine ecosystems and its potential vulnerability to rapid human-induced environmental change,” lead author Hidde Bakker and colleagues said.
How the fossils were dated
Microscopic algae cysts preserved in sediment attached to one skull provided the chronological anchor. Dinoflagellate biostratigraphy placed the specimens firmly in the Gelasian, the earliest stage of the Pleistocene, between 2.6 and 2.1 million years ago. The method is standard for North Sea Basin sediments where volcanic ash layers for radiometric dating are absent.
What the anatomy shows
Table: Key measurements and traits of the Early Pleistocene Orcinus sp. versus the only other recognized fossil species and modern Antarctic Type A males.
| Taxon | Estimated length | Tooth sockets | Condylar fossae | Inferred diet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orcinus citoniensis (Pliocene, Italy) | ~3.5 m | Small, closely spaced | Shallow | Piscivorous |
| Orcinus sp. (Gelasian, North Sea) | 7.2–7.7 m | Large, deep, widely separated | Deeply excavated | Macroraptorial |
| Orcinus orca Type A (modern, Antarctic) | Mean ~7.8 m, up to 9 m | Large, deep | Deeply excavated | Macroraptorial |
The deeply excavated condylar fossae on the atlas-axis complexes indicate the animal could move its head forcefully in multiple planes — a mechanical prerequisite for shaking and tearing large prey. The widely spaced, deep alveoli imply strong, conical teeth capable of withstanding high bite loads. Together with the body-size estimate, the morphology meets the criteria for macroraptorial feeding used in studies of fossil sperm whales and shark-toothed dolphins.
Open questions
The fragmentary nature of the material means the specimens could represent more than one species, though each bone independently displays features consistent with a large Orcinus-like dolphin. The researchers refer the material to Orcinus sp. pending more complete cranial material. No stomach contents or bite marks on contemporaneous bones have been found, so the exact prey spectrum remains unknown.
The Natural History Museum Rotterdam, founded in 1927 by the Rotterdam section of the Dutch Natural History Association, holds an estimated 400,000 objects. Its researchers collaborate on international paleontological studies, including the analysis of Pleistocene marine mammals trawled from the North Sea floor.
Publication details
Hidde Bakker, Klaas Post, Dirk K. Munsterman, Giovanni Bianucci and Alberto Collareta, “A large orca from the Lower Pleistocene of the Southern North Sea Basin pushes back the origin of macropredatory behavior in the oceanic dolphins (Odontoceti, Delphinidae),” PeerJ 14: e21890 (10 November 2026).