French activists and lawmakers are demanding a suspension of tear gas use by police following reports of potential reproductive health issues linked to the chemical irritant.
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez has rejected these requests, maintaining that the substance remains an essential tool for crowd control.
The controversy follows a series of street protests in France, including demonstrations over the cost of living and student-led actions. While police argue that tear gas serves as a necessary alternative to more dangerous weapons, protesters and advocacy groups have raised concerns about its impact on menstrual cycles and pregnancies.
According to the advocacy group “Lacrymos de sang,” or “Tears of blood,” more than 10,000 complaints have been collected from individuals who believe their health was affected by exposure. Eva-Luna Tholance of the group, said that many accounts describe symptoms ranging from mild to severe.
“Some people experience mild cramps, but a huge number tell us about cramps that are far worse than what they normally experience during their periods,” Tholance told AP News. She added that reports have included unexpected bleeding in postmenopausal individuals and those using hormonal contraception.
| Symptom | Percentage of Respondents |
|---|---|
| Uterine cramps | 59% |
| Ovarian pain | 43% |
| Bleeding between periods | 32% |
| Abnormally heavy bleeding | 25% |
These figures, reported by Le Temps as part of a dataset presented to the National Assembly on November 17, were based on 9,480 testimonies collected by the Blood Lacrymosa collective between October 8 and 31. The data also indicated that among 47 pregnant women who testified, 15 reported miscarriages, a rate described as twice that expected in the general population.
Individual testimonies further highlight personal accounts of physical distress. Mélina Galland, a 24-year-old photographer, reported feeling intense abdominal pain following the October 17 protests in Paris. “Heading back home, I felt intense belly pain which was unusual because I never experience pain that intense at that stage of my period,” she told AP News.
Despite these accounts, the Interior Ministry said that no published scientific studies confirm a causal link between the chemical irritant CS—the primary component in French tear gas grenades—and reproductive health issues. While the ministry acknowledged that skin and eye irritation may persist, it maintains that other symptoms generally resolve within hours.
Researchers have said that current evidence remains inconclusive.
Asha Hassan, lead author of a Minnesota Medical School study focused on the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests, said that while theories exist regarding reproductive impacts, “We don’t really 100% know.” Similar sentiments were echoed by ABC News, which reported that scientists have not yet confirmed a medical connection, prompting calls for more rigorous, independent research.
Laurent Nuñez, who has served as Minister of the Interior since October 12, 2025, draws upon extensive experience in law enforcement and intelligence, including his tenure as Prefect of Police of Paris from 2022 to 2025. His background also includes serving as Secretary of State to the Minister of the Interior from 2018 to 2020, where he was responsible for coordinating police and intelligence services.
In his current role, Nuñez defends the use of tear gas by arguing that the substance remains an essential tool for crowd control. He justifies this position by noting that the Interior Ministry has found no published scientific studies that confirm a causal link between the chemical irritant CS and the reproductive health issues reported by protesters.
Related reading