Swabs used during routine cervical screenings do not cause cancer, despite social media claims linking sterilization residue to the disease, gezondheidenwetenschap.be reported.
The claim surfaced after a nurse raised concerns with the Misinformation Rapid Response Team, a collaboration between Gezondheidenwetenschap.be, Factcheck.Vlaanderen, and several hospitals. Social media users have argued that plastic brushes used to collect cervical cells pose a cancer risk because manufacturers sterilize them with ethylene oxide. Similar claims previously targeted nasal swabs used during COVID-19 testing.
Sterilization via Ethylene Oxide
Ethylene oxide is a gas that manufacturers use to eliminate germs from medical equipment that cannot withstand high temperatures, including the small plastic brushes used for Pap smears. After the sterilization process, manufacturers ventilate the material to remove the gas.
Strict safety standards regulate the small amounts of residue that may remain. Ethylene oxide has also been used to decontaminate food products, such as sesame seeds.
Carcinogenic Hazard Classifications
The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies ethylene oxide among substances that can cause cancer in humans, according to the IARC Monographs on the Identification of Carcinogenic Hazards to Humans. This classification indicates the potential hazard of a substance rather than the actual risk of a specific exposure.
Risk depends heavily on dose, duration, and frequency. Everyday substances such as alcohol and sunlight also fall into this broad hazard group. Short-term exposure differs significantly from long-term occupational contact.
Medical Device Residue Levels Stay Below Safety Limits
International standard ISO 10993-7 establishes limits for residues of ethylene oxide and ethylene chlorohydrin on medical devices. A Taiwanese laboratory study published in 2024 tested 10 sterilized medical devices to measure these trace amounts. Researchers found no measurable ethylene oxide on four devices and recorded very low levels of ethylene chlorohydrin on two cotton swabs. Those measurements stayed more than 200 times below the current safety limit for short-term adult contact.
Animal studies and research on industrial workers show that inhaling ethylene oxide over many years can increase health risks. A large American mortality analysis published in 2004 followed 18,235 factory workers exposed to the gas. Researchers found no general increase in overall cancer deaths, though workers with the highest exposure levels showed elevated risks for certain blood and lymph node cancers.
Unlike industrial workers who inhaled the gas for years, a patient undergoes a cervical smear where a swab touches the cervix for only a few seconds every few years. The human body also produces small amounts of ethylene oxide naturally through liver function and gut bacteria, as outlined in a comprehensive review of total exposure pathways.
Worth a look