Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority, according to a historic ruling delivered at the International Court of Justice in The Hague.
“Mit neun zu sechs Stimmen hat der Gerichtshof festgestellt, dass die Republik der Union Myanmar einen Völkermord an der Gruppe der Rohingya im nördlichen Rakhaing-Staat unter Verstoß gegen ihre Verpflichtungen aus der Konvention über die Verhütung und Bestrafung des Völkermordes begangen hat,” Yuji Iwasawa said, according to Juedische Allgemeine.
By a vote of nine to six, the United Nations’ highest judicial body established that the military regime acted with the specific intent to destroy the group in northern Rakhine State. It marks the first time any state has been internationally condemned for committing genocide.
Gambia initiated the landmark legal proceedings against Myanmar in 2019, backed by several other countries including Germany. The UN court handles legal disputes exclusively between nations rather than prosecuting individual war criminals.
Reading the 191-page ruling, court president Yuji Iwasawa detailed how security forces killed at least 10,000 Rohingya, subjected women to widespread sexual violence, burned villages, and drove hundreds of thousands across the border into Bangladesh.
The judges evaluated extensive evidence regarding the military campaign. They concluded that while only a fraction of the total Rohingya population was killed, the systematic destruction of their livelihoods and communities met the legal threshold for genocidal intent.
The court identified three specific violations of the Genocide Convention. These included enforcing birth and marriage restrictions, denying official birth registrations, and utilizing sexual violence to prevent births within the targeted population.
NEWS: @CIJ_ICJ determines Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya during the 2017 clearance operations in northern Rakhine State.@antonioguterres calls the judgement a demonstration of international justice.https://t.co/1RCbI9g5hb pic.twitter.com/E51EwzIIDf
However, the court rejected the allegation that Myanmar intentionally worsened living conditions to bring about physical destruction. Judges also voted 14 to 1 to dismiss Gambia’s specific claim that Myanmar violated prohibitions against public incitement to commit genocide.
The bench rejected Myanmar’s defense that military operations were solely counter-terrorism measures. The judges ruled that widespread patterns of violence against civilians, infants, and toddlers override any claims of legitimate security operations.
Legal observers note the ruling serves as a key test case for similar international lawsuits. It remains uncertain how this precedent will influence parallel proceedings at the court.
The judges also evaluated the long-standing practice of discrimination against the Rohingya, state hate propaganda directed against them, the targeted selection of victims by security forces, sexual violence against Rohingya women, the targeted destruction of Rohingya villages while sparing other minorities, and massive displacements as evidence of a genocide.
The International Court of Justice delivered its judgment on the merits on 19 November. Brought by The Gambia in 2019, the case concerns Myanmar’s alleged violations of the Genocide Convention against the Rohingya.
Referring to a 1949 ruling, the judges ruled that in the event of exclusive territorial control by the respondent state and its refusal to grant independent investigators access to the affected area or to conduct its own investigations, the claimant must be permitted to resort to inferences of fact and circumstantial evidence.
Keep reading