“It’s going to be subsidized,” said Zohran Mamdani, New York City Mayor, responding to questions about city-backed stores.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani dodged pointed questions on Wednesday about the economic viability of his plan to open five city-owned grocery stores, offering few details on how the locations will operate while delivering a promised 30% discount to shoppers.
During an interview at the DealBook Summit on Wednesday, New York Times columnist Andrew Ross Sorkin pressed Mamdani on the proposal by noting that traditional supermarkets already operate on razor-thin profit margins ranging from 1% to 4%.
“How is this going to work at all? Just walk through the math when you think about it,” Sorkin asked during the summit.
Mamdani replied that the municipal stores would rely on subsidies. When Sorkin followed up by asking how those subsidies would affect other supermarkets over the long term, the mayor never directly addressed the question.
Instead, Mamdani turned the conversation toward inflation and the financial struggles of everyday shoppers. He argued that public-backed stores are necessary when society deems a service essential, comparing them to public transportation or public schools.
“When society deems something necessary for the public, then we subsidize its creation and its operation,” Mamdani said.

When Sorkin pressed further, asking how he sees the subsidy affecting other supermarkets in the city long-term, Mamdani did not answer directly.
“When you were saying, ‘Explain the math to me,’ in some ways, that’s the question that New Yorkers are asking themselves every day when they go to the grocery store,” he said. “‘Explain the math to me’ of how the same thing that I used to buy a couple of years ago has now skyrocketed in price.”
“I want the public sector to be so good that the people in this room, no matter how much money they may have in their pocket, will choose to use that public sector,” he said. He added that he wants wealthy New Yorkers shopping at the stores too.
“I want these supermarkets to not just be for those who can’t afford a supermarket in their neighborhood, but frankly to be for any New Yorker,” he said. “And that’s what we want for every single aspect of the public sector: be so good that no matter how much money you have in your pocket, you think ‘this is the best thing for me.’”
“We’re going to create five, which I know might be news to a lot of Fox News viewers, because they hear about it every day, like we’re going to create a million,” he said. They are cheaper supermarkets.”
Critics Question City Subsidies and Taxpayer Risk
The mayor’s request for proposals states that the city will use taxpayer money to build the stores, pay rent and property taxes, and cover operator losses from the discounts. However, the plan features no guaranteed returns for taxpayers if the stores turn a profit.
David Ortega, a food economist at Michigan State University, wrote in an August essay for Vital City that the initiative functions as a subsidy delivered through a storefront rather than a structural fix for food prices.
“It pays part of the food bill on the shopper’s behalf, with tax dollars,” Ortega wrote, as the New York Post reported.
The Multicultural Business Coalition also filed a class-action lawsuit against the administration regarding the store rollout.
The RFP bars operators from limiting the discounts by income. Ortega warned the model has limits.
Common Questions About the Store Proposal
Who will operate the city-owned grocery stores?
The administration’s request for proposals calls for private operators to run the five planned locations while utilizing public funds for construction, rent, property taxes, and loss coverage.
What specific discounts are promised to shoppers?
The city has pledged that the stores will sell food staples at an average of 30% below standard retail prices, without imposing income restrictions on shoppers.
How do supermarkets normally maintain profitability?
Traditional grocery stores rely on high-volume sales to stay afloat because they operate on thin net profit margins between 1% and 4%, according to industry data cited during the DealBook Summit.
Keep reading