International Edition
Latest News
News

Indonesia Minister: Javan Rhino Relocation Idea Dates to 1980s, Not Hashim

Indonesian Forestry Minister Raja Juli Antoni said Thursday the proposal to establish a second habitat for the critically endangered Javan rhino dates back to the 1980s, rejecting claims the idea originated from presidential climate envoy Hashim Djojohadikusumo. The…

Indonesian Forestry Minister Raja Juli Antoni said Thursday the proposal to establish a second habitat for the critically endangered Javan rhino dates back to the 1980s, rejecting claims the idea originated from presidential climate envoy Hashim Djojohadikusumo.

The clarification came as environmental groups, lawmakers, and local residents raised alarms over the plan to move some rhinos from Ujung Kulon National Park in Banten to Alas Purwo National Park in East Java. WALHI, Indonesia’s largest environmental forum, alleged the translocation push is linked to gold mining expansion around Ujung Kulon, a charge the ministry denies.

“There is misleading information that the idea to move or translocate the Javan rhino from Ujung Kulon to Alas Purwo originated from Mr. Hashim. It did not,” Raja Juli said in a video statement Thursday. “This is a study that has been done for a long time, since the 1980s. In 2015 I still read the notes on it.”

The concept of a “second habitat” or “second wild population” was developed by scientists to protect the species from natural disasters, disease outbreaks, and inbreeding depression caused by the limited habitat, the minister said. The entire global population of Javan rhinos survives only in Ujung Kulon.

Hashim, speaking at the COP31 climate conference in Antalya, Türkiye, on November 12, had cited the threat from Anak Krakatau volcano as a reason to move rhinos to Alas Purwo. “Because there is a new problem with Anak Krakatau, the center is threatened. If there is a tsunami from an earthquake or eruption, the Javan rhino could go extinct,” Hashim said, according to Kompas.

Raja Juli defended Hashim’s conservation record, citing his funding of a Sumatran tiger sanctuary in Dharmasraya, a wildlife clinic in Riau, and an orangutan conservation forest in East Kalimantan.

“He is a businessman who has a very deep, very long commitment to wildlife conservation,” the minister said.

The ministry also pledged not to issue mining permits in the Ujung Kulon area.

“My suggestion is that there should be no mining at all around Ujung Kulon. Even if there is, the forest area borrowing permit remains with me and I promise never to issue a mining permit in Ujung Kulon National Park,” Raja Juli said.

WALHI links translocation to gold mining interests

WALHI rejected the translocation plan on November 17, arguing there is no scientific evidence that Ujung Kulon can no longer support the rhino population. The group said it sees indications connecting the move to gold mining expansion around the park.

“WALHI sees indications that need to be investigated further regarding the possible connection between the discourse of moving the Javan rhino and the interests of gold mining around the Ujung Kulon area,” the organization said.

It urged the government to halt the plan until an independent, transparent, and accountable scientific study is completed.

“The safety of the Javan rhino must not be sacrificed for the interests of investment and natural resource exploitation,” said Umi, a WALHI campaigner.

Experts urge comprehensive study before relocation

Academics from Brawijaya University (UB) said relocation is scientifically possible but must be preceded by comprehensive study and legal review. Ir. Mokhamad Asyief Khasan Budiman, a forestry lecturer, noted Alas Purwo falls within the species’ historical biogeographical range, which once extended to eastern Java, according to detiknews.

“However, we need to distinguish between having been a habitat and still being a suitable habitat today,” Asyief said. He listed feed availability, water sources, roaming space, carrying capacity, and area security as key criteria.

Andreas Bandang Hardian of UB’s Faculty of Veterinary Medicine warned that Alas Purwo has a drier local climate with lower humidity than western Java. Environmental differences could challenge the rhinos’ physiological adaptation, potentially affecting reproductive status and immune systems.

He also cited health risks from transport stress and habituation, compounded by limited medical reference data for the endemic species.

“This is a strategic conservation action that must be ecologically and legally accountable,” Bandang said.

Menteri Kehutanan Raja Juli Antoni Pastikan Pemindahan Badak Jawa Masih Dikaji — Tribun Kaltim Official

Lawmakers demand comprehensive review; local officials reject plan

House of Representatives Commission IV Chair Siti Hediati “Titiek” Soeharto demanded a thorough review before any translocation proceeds. “We want this studied first. It must be studied properly because this concerns a rare rhino. You can’t just move them like that,” Titiek told reporters at the parliament complex Thursday.

She warned that if the move is driven by mining interests, the mining should be deferred for future generations.

“If the reason is actually mining, then let the mining wait for our grandchildren,” she said.

The Ujung Kulon National Park Authority (BTNUK) formally rejected the relocation plan Thursday after hundreds of Pandeglang residents demonstrated at its office.

Didik Sujianto, head of the park’s general administration, read a written statement saying translocation “should not be carried out before all aspects have been studied thoroughly and the results can be scientifically accounted for.”

In a November 16 press release, the Ministry of Forestry said that Ujung Kulon remains the primary habitat and top protection priority. The development of a second habitat is framed as a complementary long-term strategy to reduce risks from volcanic activity, tsunamis, and earthquakes.

“Protection of Ujung Kulon and exploration of a second habitat are two conservation efforts that complement each other,” said Ristianto Pribadi, head of the ministry’s Public Relations and International Cooperation Bureau.

“Ujung Kulon must continue to be maintained as the main habitat, while every opportunity to develop additional populations is prepared carefully and responsibly.”

The ministry cited a newborn calf spotted on October 10 as proof that the Ujung Kulon ecosystem remains viable. The calf, offspring of a female named Desy, was the fifth recorded birth from that mother since 2013.

Raja Juli Antoni, born 13 July 1977, serves as Minister of Forestry and Secretary General of the Indonesian Solidarity Party (PSI), which he helped found. He previously held the post of Deputy Minister of Agrarian Affairs and Spatial Planning from June 2022 to October 2024. A former chair of the Muhammadiyah Student Association, he earned a PhD from the University of Queensland in 2010 with a dissertation on religious peacebuilding in Mindanao and Maluku.

Indonesia Minister: Javan Rhino Relocation Idea Dates to 1980s, Not Hashim
Photo: Prasetya UB

Ministry awaits scientific recommendation

The ministry maintains any decision will await scientific recommendation. “We will never make a decision without a recommendation from scientists,” Raja Juli said.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.