International Edition
Latest News
Business

Investigation: How Florida Property Insurance Policies Changed Over a Decade

Thousands of property insurance policy changes swept across Florida as insurers adjusted coverage terms over a ten-year span. Two news organizations, the Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel, analyzed policy documents submitted to state regulators to track…

Investigation: How Florida Property Insurance Policies Changed Over a Decade

Thousands of property insurance policy changes swept across Florida as insurers adjusted coverage terms over a ten-year span.

Two news organizations, the Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel, analyzed policy documents submitted to state regulators to track how coverage shifted for homeowners.

The investigation examined records from the state Insurance Regulatory Filing System covering the decade leading up to June 2026. Researchers focused on the ten largest property insurers by policy count in Florida, alongside two major new market entrants.

The analyzed insurers included American Integrity Insurance, Citizens Property Insurance, First Protective Insurance, and Florida Peninsula Insurance. Heritage Property & Casualty, Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty, State Farm Florida Insurance, and Tower Hill Insurance also underwent review.

Universal Property & Casualty and United Services Automobile Association completed the roster of top ten established firms. Researchers also incorporated records for Slide Insurance and Manatee Insurance Exchange, the two largest companies to enter the Florida market during the decade.

AI Tools Tracked Regulatory Filings

To process the massive volume of paperwork, the news organizations utilized the artificial intelligence assistant Claude, developed by Anthropic. Dozens of public insurance adjusters helped identify the most significant policy topics for the AI to track from January 2016 onward.

Investigation: How Florida Property Insurance Policies Changed Over a Decade
Photo: sun-sentinel.com

Every change detected by the AI assistant was traced back to primary documents within the regulatory database. A data journalist conducted the initial review, and two additional journalists independently validated each conclusion.

Journalists also reviewed hundreds of actual homeowners insurance policies obtained through court legal filings across various Florida counties. This step verified whether state-approved policy alterations actually appeared in consumer coverage contracts.

A numerical analysis of Office of Insurance Regulation approval rates revealed an increasing frequency of proposed policy alterations. The review additionally tallied a significant rise in insurers applying trade secret stamps to block their proposals from public view.

Responses From Insurers and Public Opinion

All 12 insurance companies received the findings for review before publication. Five of the firms — Citizens, Heritage, Slide, State Farm, and Universal — responded with varying degrees of detail. Olympus Insurance also offered insights into the regulatory process and the reasons behind specific policy adjustments.

To gauge consumer sentiment, the reporting incorporated results from a July opinion poll of 1,511 Florida homeowners. The University of North Florida’s Public Opinion Research Lab oversaw the polling process.

Interviews and email exchanges supplemented the documentary record. Journalists spoke with insurance company representatives, lawyers, consumer advocates, state officials, academic experts, public adjusters, and homeowners.

Investigation Partners, Subsidiaries and Poll Sample Detailed

Which news organizations and university centers conducted the investigation?

The Orlando Sentinel and South Florida Sun Sentinel led the research, with support from the University of Maryland’s Howard Center for Investigative Journalism.

Which insurance subsidiaries were included in the Tower Hill analysis?

The review covered Tower Hill Prime and Tower Hill Insurance Exchange, noting that the latter took over Tower Hill Prime’s home insurance books in 2022.

How many Florida homeowners participated in the July opinion poll?

A total of 1,511 Florida homeowners participated in the July opinion poll overseen by the University of North Florida’s Public Opinion Research Lab.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.