In a new column for The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com, an Iranian-American activist and former Muslim argues that Americans must examine traditional Islamic doctrines to protect constitutional rights from religious coercion.
The author, writing under a pseudonym, draws on her 15-year experience as a devoutly practicing Sunni Muslim to raise concerns about the intersection of religious law and political governance. She compares these foundational teachings with the historical backdrop of the 1979 Iranian revolution, which she and her family fled.
The essay questions whether modern political discourse in the United States adequately addresses the legal and social implications of traditional Islamic jurisprudence.
The author points to recent events, such as a 2023 vote by the all-Muslim city council in Hamtramck, Michigan, which prohibited Pride flags and other political and religious flags on city property.
“His family came from Egypt; mine came from Iran,” she writes, referencing Senator-elect Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed. She says that hearing him use phrases like “Inshallah” and “Alhamdulillah” during his victory speech prompted her to question the boundary between public faith and political ideology.
Lessons from the 1979 Iranian Revolution
Before the 1979 revolution, Iran modernized under the Shah, a period when women gained more freedoms and legal protections. The author recalls that her mother married in the 1960s wearing a miniskirt wedding dress and a beehive hairstyle.
Following the revolution, religious authorities took control, imposing compulsory hijab laws, removing female judges from their positions, and eventually reducing the minimum marriage age for girls.
Political dissent was suppressed, and religious minorities faced persecution.
The author argues that Iran demonstrates what can happen when religious authority becomes inseparable from state power. Nearly 47 years after the revolution, opposition leader Reza Pahlavi continues to emerge as a prominent figure.
During protests in January 2026, millions of protesters responded to his call for freedom and faced deadly repression, with an independent medical documentation report estimating approximately 54,200 deaths during the January crackdown.
Critiquing Religious Doctrines While Respecting Constitutional Rights
The author emphasizes that her critique targets religious doctrines rather than individual Muslims. She says that while individuals have every constitutional right to practice and express their religion, Americans deserve to understand traditional teachings regarding apostasy, unequal treatment of women, and corporal punishments.
Her personal journey involved studying more than 100 Islamic books, wearing the hijab, and completing the obligatory Hajj pilgrimage to Mecca.
Over time, she questioned specific interpretations, including those surrounding Aisha’s marriage age as traditionally described in Sahih al-Bukhari and Quranic verse 4:34, which many Islamic scholars traditionally interpret as permitting husbands to strike disobedient wives, provided the strike is considered “light” and does not leave a mark.
After spending 15 years practicing Islam devoutly, she eventually rejected the belief that her “good works” or strict religious obedience could earn her a place in God’s kingdom and embraced Christianity. Her primary concern centers on movements seeking to impose Islamic religious doctrines through democratic institutions that conflict with equality, personal freedom, and constitutional rights.
Questions About the Author's Motivations and Historical Comparisons
* What prompted the author to write about her experiences? As an Iranian-American activist and former Muslim who practiced Islam devoutly for 15 years, she felt compelled to speak out to ensure America’s future does not resemble the nightmare that began in Iran in 1979.
* What specific historical event does the author compare modern concerns against?
She points to the 1979 Iranian revolution, which led to religious authorities taking control, the imposition of compulsory hijab laws, and the suppression of political dissent.
* How many casualties were reported during recent unrest in Iran? An independent medical documentation report estimated approximately 54,200 deaths during the deadly crackdown on protesters in January 2026.