International Edition
Latest News
World

Ireland Opposes EU Digital Tax in Costa’s Revised Budget Plan

European Council President António Costa unveiled a revised seven-year budget proposal on Saturday that cuts €204 billion from the European Commission’s original plan and introduces a new EU-wide tax on large digital companies to help fund the bloc’s…

Ireland Opposes EU Digital Tax in Costa's Revised Budget Plan

European Council President António Costa unveiled a revised seven-year budget proposal on Saturday that cuts €204 billion from the European Commission’s original plan and introduces a new EU-wide tax on large digital companies to help fund the bloc’s spending from 2028 to 2034.

The negotiating box presented by Costa reduces the Commission’s initial €1.76 trillion proposal to €1.58 trillion in constant 2025 prices, a 10 per cent reduction, according to The Irish Times. The plan would still represent an increase of about a quarter in real terms over the current budget, though that falls to 16 per cent when excluding repayments of post-pandemic borrowings.

Taoiseach Micheál Martin said Ireland would not support the digital services tax, arguing it risks reopening a global tax agreement and triggering a trade dispute with the United States. “We would not support [digital taxation] … global taxation was meant to be dealt with by the BEPS (Base Erosion and Profit Shifting) process,” Martin said. “Global taxation has to be done globally. Europe would lose a lot of investment if it just goes ahead unilaterally with a digital tax.”

Martin said Ireland had cooperated with the OECD process and changed its corporation tax structure on the understanding that a digital tax would not be pursued. “That was a commitment that was made to Ireland at the time on the base of Ireland changing its corporation tax structure,” he said. He warned that a unilateral EU move “would risk reopening the trade deal with the US and cause a very negative EU-US escalation.”

According to The Irish Times, the proposed levy would impose a 3 per cent rate on revenues from online advertising, digital marketplaces and the monetisation of user data for companies with global annual turnover exceeding €750 million and EU digital revenues above €50 million. The Commission previously estimated such a tax would raise about €5 billion a year, or €35 billion over the seven-year period.

Costa replaced an earlier Commission proposal for a tax on large companies — which faced opposition from Germany and others — with the digital services tax in a bid to raise new revenue streams and limit the rise in national contributions to 0.82 per cent of gross national income, up from 0.80 per cent.

“This tax is not targeting a specific company as such or any country as such, but … the aim is to ensure healthy competitiveness in our economy and fair taxation for our businesses and all businesses that operate in our market,” Costa said.

France, Italy, Spain and Austria already operate national digital services levies. Any EU-wide tax requires unanimous backing from all 27 member states. The United States opted out of the OECD global tax agreement after Donald Trump’s re-election in 2024, undermining the multilateral framework that had previously stalled EU unilateral action.

Largest budget cuts hit competitiveness and external action

The largest reduction in Costa’s proposal falls on the competitiveness, innovation and security heading, which shrinks by €84.5 billion, or 16.2 per cent, compared with the Commission’s original plan. Outlays on external action, including aid and funding for potential future member states, were reduced by 21 per cent, leaving them 23 per cent higher than the current budget.

Agriculture and cohesion funding — which together have historically absorbed two-thirds of EU spending — were reduced by 5.1 per cent. When pandemic-era debt repayments are excluded, that represents a 6.5 per cent cut compared with the current budget, The Irish Times reported.

Administrative spending would rise by 12 per cent from the current budget.

Costa also proposed allocating 30 per cent of revenues from the main EU emissions trading system to the budget, increasing the EU’s share of carbon border tax revenues from 75 per cent to 100 per cent, and raising a tax on uncollected electronic waste.

Repayments to bondholders for the post-pandemic recovery fund would be cut by about €9 billion, or roughly €1.4 billion per year, under a new repayment profile.

Reactions split along national lines

Dóchas, the Irish network of international development and humanitarian organisations, said further cuts to foreign aid were short-sighted. “If this proposal is adopted it will hurt millions facing severe hunger, conflict, and climate breakdown,” said its chief executive Jane-Ann McKenna. “Whatever way it’s dressed up, the CAP allocation to Ireland remains well short of the allocation to CAP under the 2021 to 2027 EU budget,” said its president Francie Gorman. “Our CAP campaign will continue to fight tooth and nail for a better deal to be put on the table for a potential outcome in December.” Seventeen member states have formed a “Friends of Cohesion” group pushing for greater funding for agriculture and regional development.

The French presidency called the proposal “deeply disappointing” and said it “falls well short of what is needed, particularly on the Common Agricultural Policy, notably to guarantee income support for farmers.” “As it stands, this proposal from the president of the European Council does not provide a basis for an agreement,” the French presidency added.

Siegfried Mureșan, a key budget politician in the European Parliament, warned the assembly would block the spending plan if member states continued to ignore its concerns. “We think that the debate … is focused too much on cuts,” he said this week, according to RTÉ.

Summit set for November with December deadline in view

EU leaders will gather for a special summit on November 26-27 to discuss the negotiating box. Martin said he did not expect an agreement at that meeting. “I think it’s a meeting to discuss the negotiating box and I think this will go into December,” he said.

Costa expressed confidence the proposal provides a good basis for moving towards a deal.

“I believe this proposal can bring us closer to a final agreement,” he told a press conference in Brussels. Many leaders are keen to reach an agreement before elections in France, Italy and Poland in the coming months. The budget requires unanimous backing from all 27 countries and subsequent approval by the European Parliament.

Ireland Opposes EU Digital Tax in Costa's Revised Budget Plan
Photo: RTÉ

FAQ

What is the proposed EU digital services tax rate and who would pay it?

The proposal sets a 3 per cent levy on revenues from online advertising, digital marketplaces and user data monetisation for companies with global turnover above €750 million and EU digital revenues exceeding €50 million.

Why does Ireland oppose the digital tax?

Ireland argues the tax would violate a commitment made during the OECD BEPS process, under which Ireland raised its corporate tax rate in exchange for a standstill on unilateral digital taxes. The government warns it could trigger a trade conflict with the United States.

Ireland, an island in the North Atlantic Ocean, is divided between the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland, which remains part of the United Kingdom. The Republic joined the European Economic Community in 1973, while Northern Ireland left the EU in 2020 but operates within the single market for goods under a special status.

The island’s population exceeds 7 million, with 5.1 million in the Republic. Ireland became a republic in 1949 after a war of independence and partition in the early 20th century.

When is the next key deadline for the EU budget talks?

EU leaders meet for a special summit on November 26-27, but Taoiseach Micheál Martin expects negotiations to continue into December before a potential agreement.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.