Italy’s highest court upheld a life sentence Thursday for Giampaolo Amato, a former team doctor for the Virtus Bologna basketball club and a noted ophthalmologist, confirming his conviction for poisoning his wife and mother-in-law with a cocktail of anesthetic drugs in October 2021, according to Sky.
The Court of Cassation’s first criminal section rejected the appeal filed by Amato’s defense team, led by prominent attorneys Franco Coppi and Valerio Spigarelli, after nearly seven hours of deliberation, according to Ansa. The ruling makes the ergastolo — Italy’s maximum penalty — definitive. Amato has been in custody since his arrest in 2023.
Prosecutors alleged Amato used a mixture of sevoflurane, an inhaled anesthetic, and midazolam, a sedative, to kill his 87-year-old mother-in-law, Giulia Tateo, on October 9, 2021, and his 62-year-old wife, gynecologist Isabella Linsalata, in the night between October 30 and 31 that same year. The first death was treated by investigators as a "trial run" for the second, according to the prosecution’s reconstruction reported by Sky TG24.
A "perfect crime" motive
Deputy Prosecutor General Simone Perelli told the court the double murder was conceived as a "perfect crime" designed to "close his past, eliminating those who could represent an obstacle." The prosecution identified a dual motive: Amato’s desire to freely pursue a relationship with a younger woman and a financial interest in securing his inheritance rights to his wife’s substantial assets before a separation could diminish them.

The Bologna Court of Assizes on Appeal, in its January ruling confirming the first-instance life sentence, described the case as "a reiterated murder dictated exclusively by selfish motives, which define a personality trait devoid of humanly or ethically understandable profiles." The appellate judges called the evidentiary framework against Amato "granitic" and his conduct "not only premeditated, but also coldly and lucidly executed with great cunning."
The evidentiary battle
The conviction rests on circumstantial evidence. No direct proof — such as a confession or eyewitness — linked Amato to the administration of the drugs. The defense argued consistently that the "granitic" label was overstated, maintaining that the investigation failed to establish how Amato could have administered volatile anesthetics to two victims in a domestic setting without detection.
Amato has always proclaimed his innocence. His son, Nicola Amato, also a physician, defended his father in an interview with la Repubblica on the eve of the Cassation hearing. "He is innocent because there is no direct evidence against him and the case should not be closed," the younger Amato said, adding that he and his sister had not been "subjugated" by their father.
Suspicions and arrest
The investigation was triggered by Isabella Linsalata’s sister, Anna Maria Linsalata, who became the first to voice suspicions. She joined the proceedings as a civil party represented by attorney Maurizio Merlini. The probe focused on Amato’s professional access to the anesthetic agents detected in the victims’ toxicological analyses.
The Court of Assizes in Bologna handed down the initial life sentence. The Court of Appeal confirmed it in January. With the Supreme Court’s rejection of the final appeal, the judgment is now res judicata — no further appeals are possible.
Bologna, where the trial unfolded, is the capital of Emilia-Romagna and Italy’s seventh-largest city with 391,473 inhabitants. It hosts the world’s oldest university in continuous operation, founded in 1088, where Dante, Boccaccio and Petrarch studied and the medieval medical school was especially renowned. Its historic centre, famed for towers and lengthy porticoes, became a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2021.
What happens next
Amato will serve the life sentence under Italy’s standard penitentiary regulations. The definitive conviction also opens the civil phase for the quantification of damages owed to the civil parties, including Anna Maria Linsalata. The court’s written motivations, expected to be deposited within 90 days, will detail the legal reasoning that overcame the defense’s arguments on the circumstantial nature of the proof.
Keep reading