International Edition
Latest News
News

Whanganui Collegiate School Allowed to Continue Charging Day Students $11,000 Fee for School Activities

Whanganui Collegiate School can keep charging day students nearly $11,000 a year for access to boarding-house facilities and inter-house sports after a District Court challenge was struck out at the end of October. The ruling followed an Ombudsman’s…

Whanganui Collegiate School Allowed to Continue Charging Day Students ,000 Fee for School Activities

Whanganui Collegiate School can keep charging day students nearly $11,000 a year for access to boarding-house facilities and inter-house sports after a District Court challenge was struck out at the end of October.

The ruling followed an Ombudsman’s investigation that found the fee structure did not appear to be unlawful, RNZ reported. The decision allows the state-integrated school to continue excluding students who do not pay from activities such as cross-country races, swimming sports and house music competitions that take place during school hours.

Craig Sinclair, who brought the court case, said the fee covers activities that form part of the school’s special Anglican character and occur in regular timetabled hours. “The ministry at the moment have got an opinion that what Whanganui Collegiate School is offering is a very high-quality, expensive, after-school programme and that is a load of nonsense because the cross-country is during school time, the swimming sports is during school time, quite a few of these things are during school time,” Sinclair told RNZ.

Sinclair said he is preparing an appeal. He warned the precedent could let other state and state-integrated schools charge high fees for standard activities, eroding Section 33 of the Education and Training Act, which guarantees free education for New Zealanders aged five to 19.

Long-time campaigner Guy Gifford, who lodged the Ombudsman’s complaint, said the fee model deprives families of donation tax credits worth thousands of dollars.

“A lot of the individual parents would be happy to pay, they want to pay. They want to contribute to their children’s education and get something a bit better than the state provides but the act is designed not to let them — you must operate at the level of a state school,” Gifford told RNZ.

Association of Proprietors of Integrated Schools chief executive Kevin Shore said schools have always been able to charge for services such as overseas trips and magazines rather than seek donations. He said financial pressure could drive more proprietors to make optional services contingent on payment.

“There’s no doubt this sets a precedent and it sets a precedent for state schools as well as state integrated schools,” Shore told RNZ. “Will it increase the amount of schools that are doing this? Time will tell, I suppose.”

The Ministry of Education separately confirmed the school had fixed a lease arrangement that breached education legislation.

RNZ reported in April that the school had been paying the Whanganui Collegiate School Foundation for use of a hockey turf, though only a proprietor may hold property leases. The ministry said the proprietor now leases the turf for the school’s use, bringing the agreement into line with the integration agreement and legal requirements.

The school did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.