International Edition
Latest News
Business

Ken Ono on AI, Riemann Hypothesis Claim and Mentoring

In a column for The Guardian, mathematician Ken Ono argues that the emergence of AI in research necessitates a new framework for mentoring and academic integrity. His comments follow the announcement on November 20 by Levent Alpöge, who…

Ken Ono on AI, Riemann Hypothesis Claim and Mentoring

In a column for The Guardian, mathematician Ken Ono argues that the emergence of AI in research necessitates a new framework for mentoring and academic integrity.

His comments follow the announcement on November 20 by Levent Alpöge, who claimed to have used Anthropic’s Claude chatbot to prove the 167-year-old Riemann hypothesis.

  • Levent Alpöge announced a proof of the Riemann hypothesis on November 20, using Anthropic’s Claude AI.
  • The Riemann hypothesis, a 167-year-old problem regarding the distribution of prime numbers, remains unverified by the broader mathematical community.
  • OpenAI reported in September that its models solved a component of the Navier-Stokes equations in 88 hours.

Mathematical Research in the AI Era

While the proof has been shared with the Lean and Mathlib communities for certification, independent experts have yet to review the full argument. “It’s a monumental moment in human history,” Brian Conrey, a specialist on the Riemann hypothesis, told SBS, noting that he had not yet seen the manuscript. The use of AI to address long-standing problems has sparked debate regarding the future of the field.

In his column, Ono, a professor at the University of Virginia currently working at Axiom Math, writes that he initially feared AI would represent an abandonment of mathematics. However, he now argues that AI can assist in formalizing and verifying complex proofs, such as the classification of finite simple groups, which required 43.1 million lines of Lean code.

The Riemann hypothesis is widely considered the single most famous problem in mathematics, in large part due to its complexity. “A whole bunch of people have just been doing that for a long time, assuming that the Riemann Hypothesis is true,” she said.

Kevin Buzzard said that while the Riemann hypothesis has applications to neighboring fields, it is not the hardest problem in mathematics, pointing to stronger versions such as the extended and grand Riemann hypotheses. “The Riemann hypothesis is just, in some sense, at the foot of a mountain,” he said.

Concerns Over Academic Standards

Despite his work with AI, Ken Ono joins other scholars in signing a declaration stating that companies using AI to demonstrate commercial sophistication can be detrimental to the science of mathematics, as some scholars view the rapid deployment of AI as a threat to intellectual work.

“We are witnessing a general threat to intellectual work, with misalignment between the outcome of the use of AI and its initial purpose,” the scholars said in a group letter.

Ono emphasizes that universities and funding agencies must now determine how to support students who choose to work with or without these tools. Having advised 35 PhD students, 17 postdocs, and hundreds of undergraduates, he intends to prioritize human judgment and individual contribution in his own advising. “Students need room to struggle with mathematics and learn to question the tools they use,” he writes in The Guardian.

Ono’s authority stems from a distinguished career in number theory, including his service as Vice President of the American Mathematical Society from 2018 to 2021.

His perspective is further bolstered by his role as the section chair for mathematics at the American Association for the Advancement of Science, a position he held from 2020 to 2023. These leadership roles within major scientific organizations provide a foundation for his critical analysis of academic integrity in the modern research era.

Currently, Ono applies this extensive background to the intersection of technology and theory.

Anthropic's name on a video billboard in Times Square, New York, with a background of dark colors swirling around it
Photo: BBC

Alpöge’s announcement, which he described as “one dawn across science of something far greater,” came one day after Anthropic’s stock market debut, where the company raised US$81 billion at a US$1.5 trillion valuation. Regarding the shift in the field, Buzzard said that the AI process is like taking a tour through infrastructure built to reach other reserves, somehow creating a “wormhole to that destination.”

He added that “they are grieving because the field is changing rapidly, and with change comes loss.” The verification process for the Riemann hypothesis claim is expected to be lengthy. According to the rules of the Clay Mathematics Institute, a solution must be published in a peer-reviewed journal and withstand two years of scrutiny to be considered for a $1 million prize, SBS reported.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.