Labour Party leader Ivana Bacik and Cork University Hospital chief executive Jennifer Kearney emerged as the political winners of the week after sustained pressure on the HSE over patient safety concerns, while Education Minister Hildegarde Naughton and Agriculture Minister Martin Heydon faced criticism over a 250% hike in school transport fees and continued state funding for greyhound racing.
Bacik used Leaders’ Questions on Wednesday to tell Taoiseach Micheál Martin that “official Ireland” appeared engaged in a “witch-hunt” against Kearney, who raised staffing and patient safety concerns through internal channels in August before facing pushback from Health Minister Stephen Donnelly and HSE leadership. “And this begs the question: Does the government want to silence those who speak out about failings in the health service? Because the debacle has already had a chilling effect,” Bacik said in the Dáil. The confrontation followed a Health Committee session where Labour TDs Marie Sherlock and Eoghan Kenny, alongside Senator Laura Harmon, pressed HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor on the response to the CUH warnings. Kenny’s questioning led O’Connor to decline stating whether Andy Phillips, the HSE’s South West chief officer, remained in a tenable position. The Social Democrats’ Pádraig Rice, Liam McQuaid and Cian O’Callaghan, and Sinn Féin health spokesperson David Cullinane, also pursued the issue through the week. Kearney, a consultant anaesthetist, wrote to HSE management in August warning that staffing shortages at CUH posed an immediate risk to patients.
The HSE subsequently launched a review of her governance decisions, a move the Irish Hospital Consultants Association (IHCA) described as an attempt to “shoot the messenger.”
On Thursday, the Department of Education confirmed secondary school transport fees will rise from €100 to €350 per child for the 2027–2028 academic year, with the maximum family charge increasing from €220 to €650. The increase follows a doubling of primary school transport fees last year. Bus Éireann operates the scheme on behalf of the department, which sets the fees, placing direct accountability on Naughton.
“In the midst of a cost-of-living crisis, a 250% increase in the price of getting your kids to school is a tough one for any minister to try and stand over.”
Simultaneously, the Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) published a report stating the €20 million annual state subsidy to Greyhound Racing Ireland accounted for half the sector’s income in 2024, questioning its long-term viability.
Figures provided to the Public Accounts Committee showed two-thirds of racing greyhounds born between 2021 and 2024 — over 8,000 dogs — had died before age five, against a life expectancy of 10 to 14 years. Heydon defended the funding on Thursday, arguing it supports rural communities.