International Edition
Latest News
Business

Legal Victory for Mothers: Canada Forced to Amend Discriminatory Employment Insurance Law

Émilie Bellemare and five other mothers have secured a legal victory forcing the federal government to amend Canada's employment insurance legislation, which the Federal Court of Appeal ruled discriminatory against women on September 3. The government decided not…

Legal Victory for Mothers: Canada Forced to Amend Discriminatory Employment Insurance Law

Émilie Bellemare and five other mothers have secured a legal victory forcing the federal government to amend Canada’s employment insurance legislation, which the Federal Court of Appeal ruled discriminatory against women on September 3.

The government decided not to challenge the court’s ruling, a final confirmation that reached Bellemare on November 5. The legal battle, which began in 2018, centered on rules that penalized women who lost their jobs during or near their maternity and parental leaves, effectively blocking their access to regular employment insurance benefits, according to lenord-cotier.com.

Bellemare’s involvement began after she experienced two separate denials of employment insurance benefits in Sept-Îles. After the birth of her first child in 2015, she was denied coverage because she had not accumulated enough insurable hours in the 52 weeks preceding her application, a shortfall she attributed to her time spent on maternity and parental leave.

When the situation repeated after the birth of her second child, she sought support from the Mouvement Action-Chômage (MAC) in Montreal to join a collective legal challenge, according to Lenord Cotier.

Legal Victory for Mothers: Canada Forced to Amend Discriminatory Employment Insurance Law
Photo: info-web.ca

“We shouldn’t have to choose between motherhood and the choice of being protected by unemployment insurance,” Bellemare told lenord-cotier.com. She explained that the financial pressure of being denied benefits forced her to accept employment for which she was not qualified, creating further professional instability.

The Federal Court of Appeal concluded that specific provisions of the Employment Insurance Act violated the right to equality guaranteed by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. By excluding mothers who lost their jobs during leave periods from accessing regular benefits, the law created a systemic disadvantage for those without alternative financial support.

Quebec mothers win legal victory over EI against Ottawa — CTV News

The federal government now has until September 3, 2027, to implement legislative changes to bring the act into compliance with the court’s ruling. Once the law is amended, the files of the six women involved in the case will be re-examined to determine their eligibility for retroactive benefits.

While the process of receiving compensation remains pending, the victory establishes a legal precedent that could affect thousands of mothers across the country.

The Mouvement Action-Chômage, founded in 1970, is a Montreal-based advocacy group that works to defend the rights of the unemployed while pushing for improvements to the employment insurance system.

The organization, which incorporated as a non-profit in 1978 and currently counts over 500 individual members, has a long history of challenging discriminatory legislation. Notably, it previously succeeded in invalidating discriminatory laws against individuals aged 65 and over through a landmark victory at the Supreme Court of Canada.

“I am proud that my story has contributed to this great victory,” Bellemare told lenord-cotier.com. She emphasized that the primary goal of the long-running case was to ensure that future mothers would not face the same financial precariousness she endured after leaving the workforce to raise her children.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.