International Edition
Latest News
Business

Letby Lawyer Demands Urgent Appeal Review After Key Expert Barred From Practice

Lucy Letby’s lawyer, Mark McDonald, has urged the Court of Appeal to conduct an urgent review of her convictions following revelations that a key prosecution expert was barred from clinical practice while her trial was underway. The investigation,…

Letby Lawyer Demands Urgent Appeal Review After Key Expert Barred From Practice

Lucy Letby’s lawyer, Mark McDonald, has urged the Court of Appeal to conduct an urgent review of her convictions following revelations that a key prosecution expert was barred from clinical practice while her trial was underway.

The investigation, reported by the Guardian, found that Prof Peter Hindmarsh—who testified that two babies were poisoned with insulin—was excluded from treating patients by UCLH in March 2023. The jury received no information regarding this restriction, nor about a subsequent medical practitioners tribunal ruling in April 2023 that imposed conditions on his registration.

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) confirmed it was not informed of the March or April developments. Cheshire Constabulary, which instructed Hindmarsh, declined to comment.

Clinical restrictions during trial

Hindmarsh gave evidence at Manchester Crown Court during the early 2023 trial. On 23 February, lead prosecution barrister Nick Johnson KC described him to the jury as “the pre-eminent expert in that narrow field” of insulin.

The trust’s stance shifted weeks later. In March 2023, Dr Tim Hodgson, a medical director at UCLH, wrote to the General Medical Council (GMC) stating the trust was “not presently in a position to allow Prof [Hindmarsh] to practise clinically even under supervision.” Hodgson cited safety concerns, including two instances where Hindmarsh had advised child patients to stop taking insulin.

Letby Lawyer Demands Urgent Appeal Review After Key Expert Barred From Practice
Photo: aol.co.uk

“I do not believe UCLH can accept the level of risk Prof Hindmarsh appears to pose to children and young people even with close clinical supervision,” Hodgson wrote, according to the Guardian.

While the GMC applied for Hindmarsh’s registration to be suspended, a medical practitioners tribunal declined the suspension on 21 April 2023, instead ordering he work under direct clinical supervision. However, the Guardian reported that UCLH had already barred him from clinical practice entirely.

The disclosure gap

A timeline of communication shows important gaps. Hindmarsh informed Cheshire Constabulary of the GMC investigation in December 2022. While the CPS disclosed that investigation to the defence, it opposed the jury being told. The defence was not informed of the March 2023 UCLH exclusion or the April 2023 tribunal conditions.

Letby Lawyer Demands Urgent Appeal Review After Key Expert Barred From Practice
Photo: ukpulse.co.uk

The CPS told the Guardian it was never given the information about the restriction or the tribunal order. A representative for Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian’s questions, including whether he disclosed the March and April developments to the police.

Under Criminal Procedure Rules, expert witnesses must disclose anything “that might reasonably be thought capable of undermining the expert’s opinion or detract from the credibility or impartiality of the expert.” These rules were introduced in 2014 following Law Commission recommendations prompted by miscarriages of justice involving medical expert evidence, such as the Sally Clark case.

Tim Green KC, a specialist in disclosure, told the Guardian: “If there was a failure to make relevant disclosure of material undermining an expert’s opinion evidence, and where that opinion evidence was relevant to the central issues before the jury, then that failure could form part of the grounds of appeal.”

The weight of this evidence cannot be overstated in a case built on medical testimony.

Pete Weatherby KC, a barrister with extensive criminal trial experience, said: “Expert evidence was essential in the Lucy Letby prosecution because there was no direct or forensic evidence that she committed any of the criminal acts of which she was accused. Serious concerns about an expert’s conduct or judgment may be highly relevant to assessing their expertise, credibility, and the reliability of their evidence. If those concerns were not before the jury, that could be very important for an appeal.”

The push for referral

Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others, receiving 15 whole-life orders. Hindmarsh’s opinion on the two attempted murder counts involving alleged insulin poisoning was key to those convictions.

McDonald has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) to have Letby’s convictions referred back to the Court of Appeal. Since the convictions, dozens of UK and international medical and scientific experts have submitted reports to the CCRC arguing that the prosecution’s medical case, including Hindmarsh’s insulin evidence, was wrong.

“She is an innocent woman in prison, serving whole-life sentences, yet material information that could have been of critical importance to her defence was not disclosed,” McDonald said. “Did the police know? How did this information remain undisclosed? We need answers. Lucy deserves answers. She should not have to spend another day behind bars while these fundamental questions remain unanswered.”

Manchester Crown Court at Crown Square, where Letby was tried, was completed in 1962 to replace the Manchester Assize Courts, which had been badly damaged in the Manchester Blitz of 1940. Designed by city architect Leonard Cecil Howitt, the Modernist building originally housed 17 courtrooms.

A “super-courtroom” with floor area three times the size of a standard court was brought into use in September 2021, intended for gang trials and murder cases. The Letby trial concluded in August 2023, joining a list of notable cases at the venue.

The CCRC has not announced a decision on the referral application.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.