International Edition
Latest News
News

MA SJC: Parent-Signed Noncompetes Void If Employer Subsidiary Didn’t Sign

Noncompete agreements signed only by a corporate parent are legally unenforceable under Massachusetts law if the employee actually works for a subsidiary, according to a ruling issued by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court on Tuesday. The state's highest…

MA SJC: Parent-Signed Noncompetes Void If Employer Subsidiary Didn't Sign

Noncompete agreements signed only by a corporate parent are legally unenforceable under Massachusetts law if the employee actually works for a subsidiary, according to a ruling issued by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court on Tuesday.

The state’s highest court ruled against Anaplan Parent LP and Anaplan Inc. in their legal battle against former employee Timothy Brennan. The decision directly impacts how corporations structure restrictive covenants for workers across subsidiaries in the state.

Brennan worked exclusively for Anaplan Inc. but signed three equity incentive agreements with the parent company, Anaplan Parent LP. When Brennan left the subsidiary in 2025 to work for a competitor, both corporate entities filed a lawsuit to stop the move, as reported by Holland & Knight.

Lower courts rejected the companies’ request for an injunction because the actual employer, Anaplan Inc., never signed the restrictive covenants. The Supreme Judicial Court affirmed those denials, ruling that the parent company does not qualify as the employer under the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act.

Parent Company Lacks Employer Status

The Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act requires that such contracts be written and signed by both the employer and the employee. Justices concluded that an employer must be an entity where the individual performs actual services.

Brennan performed tasks only for the subsidiary rather than the parent organization. The parent company did not hire, fire, supervise, or pay Brennan, nor did it maintain his employment records.

Attorneys for the parent company argued that its active role alongside the subsidiary created a joint venture, granting it the right to enforce the agreement. Justices rejected this reasoning because both entities maintained separate corporate forms.

“Having taken advantage of the benefits of this separateness, they may not disavow that form when it is to their advantage,” the court wrote in its decision, as detailed by Holland & Knight.

Employment Relationship Scope Under State Law

The companies argued alternatively that if the parent company wasn’t the direct employer, the state statute shouldn’t apply at all because the agreement fell outside an employment relationship.

The Supreme Judicial Court disagreed with that defense. Justices determined the covenants fell squarely within the scope of the statute because they were directly tied to Brennan’s work for the subsidiary.

The equity incentive agreements named the subsidiary as a third-party beneficiary and offered parent company equity in exchange for promises not to compete with the subsidiary. Because the restrictions were tethered to the employment relationship, the statute applied directly, yet failed due to the missing signature from the actual employing entity.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Anaplan Decision

What specific document flaw invalidated the noncompete agreement?

The restriction failed because Anaplan Inc., which employed Brennan directly, never signed the equity incentive agreements. Only the parent company signed them, which violated the statutory requirement that both the employer and employee sign.

Can parent companies fix this by claiming joint employer status?

The court ruled that parent companies cannot claim joint venture liability to enforce restrictive covenants when they maintain separate corporate forms and do not hire, supervise, or pay the subsidiary’s staff.

What steps should employers take next in Massachusetts?

Legal analysts advise organizations to review all parent-level award agreements for state employees to verify that the employing subsidiary is a proper signatory. Businesses can also utilize nondisclosure and non-solicitation agreements that fall outside the scope of the state noncompete statute.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.