Controversy Surrounds Meghan Markle After Lobster Preparation Scene in “With Love, Meghan”

A scene from the second season of Netflix’s “With Love, Meghan” featuring chef José Andrés preparing a lobster has sparked online criticism, reigniting debate surrounding Meghan Markle’s public image and commitment to animal welfare. The scene, initially aired in 2025, resurfaced on social media platforms X and Instagram in March 2026, prompting accusations of cruelty and insensitivity.

The Scene and Initial Reactions

The 51-second clip shows Chef Andrés expertly carving a lobster. Meghan Markle, present during the preparation, displays visible discomfort through nervous movements and expressions. A moment where Chef Andrés refers to the lobster as a “baby” before preparing it drew particular condemnation.

Criticism and Accusations of Cruelty

Social media users quickly voiced their disapproval, labeling the scene as cruel and “unsustainable.” Critics pointed to Markle’s past public commitments to animal protection, suggesting a contradiction in her actions. Some commentators described the scene as “animal abuse.”^[1]

Impact on Meghan Markle’s Public Image

The controversy has further complicated Meghan Markle’s public image, which has been consistently scrutinized by the media and public. The scene contrasts with the values of humanity, compassion, and ethical commitment that have been central to the marketing of “With Love, Meghan.” The incident highlights the challenges of reconciling public exposure with ethical considerations in the age of social media virality.

Netflix and José Andrés’ Involvement

The Netflix production and the involvement of Chef José Andrés, known for his social and humanitarian work, add another layer to the debate. This paradox has fueled discussion and intensified the scrutiny of Markle’s actions.

“With Love, Meghan” and Recent Developments

“With Love, Meghan” is an American lifestyle television series hosted and executive produced by Meghan, Duchess of Sussex. The series premiered on Netflix on March 4, 2025, and concluded on December 3, 2025, after two seasons and 16 episodes (plus one special). ^[1] The indicate features Markle sharing cooking, gardening, and hosting tips with friends and guests. ^[2]

Recently, Netflix ended its partnership with Markle’s lifestyle brand, As Ever, though Markle will continue to grow the brand independently.^[3] Netflix as well downgraded Markle’s production deal with Archewell Productions to a first-look arrangement.^[3]

Key Takeaways

• A scene from “With Love, Meghan” featuring lobster preparation sparked controversy online.
• Critics accused Meghan Markle of hypocrisy, citing her past commitments to animal welfare.
• The incident highlights the challenges of maintaining a positive public image in the age of social media.
• Netflix has recently adjusted its partnerships with both Markle’s lifestyle brand and her production company.

The “lobster” sequence serves as a reminder of the unpredictable nature of public reactions and the immediate impact of virality on reputation. As Meghan Markle continues to navigate her public life outside of royal duties, she will likely face ongoing scrutiny and debate.