MLB Free Agency Update: Giolito, McCutchen, and Remaining Key Players

Spring Training is underway, yet a significant number of notable free agents remain unsigned as teams prepare for the 2026 season. While many franchises are optimistic, the uncertainty surrounding several past All-Stars continues to shape the offseason landscape. Securing pitchers like Lucas Giolito or Zack Littell would provide an immediate boost to any rotation, and veteran leadership from players such as Andrew McCutchen, Tommy Pham, and Starling Marte could be invaluable to contending teams.

The Lucas Giolito Situation

Right-handed pitcher Lucas Giolito is currently evaluating multiple opportunities and appears willing to wait for the most favorable offer. While the Atlanta Braves were initially considered a potential fit, recent injuries to their rotation, including Spencer Schwellenbach, haven’t prompted a serious pursuit of Giolito, according to sources. Unless further injuries occur, it’s unlikely Giolito or Littell will land with the Braves.

Will Veterans Consider Retirement?

Despite speculation, it’s unlikely that Andrew McCutchen, Starling Marte, or Tommy Pham will retire. McCutchen, particularly, is motivated to prove the Pittsburgh Pirates wrong after not being re-signed, and is actively seeking opportunities elsewhere. Marte remains a productive hitter, posting a 111 OPS+ last season, indicating he still has valuable contributions to make. Pham continues to engage with teams, following a similar pattern of signing later in the offseason, as he did with the Pittsburgh Pirates last year.

Pirates’ Pursuit of a Third Baseman

The Pittsburgh Pirates are still actively seeking a third baseman, despite ongoing conversations throughout the offseason. They have reportedly engaged with the Houston Astros regarding Isaac Paredes, but Houston values Paredes highly and is unlikely to trade him without receiving significant value in return. The Pirates may consider including a player from their Major League roster, such as catcher Joey Bart, in a potential package to acquire Paredes or another third baseman.

Why Are Free Agents Taking So Long to Sign?

The prolonged free agency period for players like Giolito, Littell, McCutchen, Pham, Randal Grichuk, Justin Turner, Tyler Anderson, and Max Scherzer is a notable trend. These are players capable of contributing to winning teams, yet they remain unsigned. Several factors may be at play, including discrepancies in player valuation, potential medical concerns, and players strategically waiting for opportunities with contenders.

Veteran left-hander Danny Coloumbe is another unsigned player whose situation is somewhat surprising, given his recent success. However, he reportedly is comfortable waiting for the right opportunity, as teams consistently seek left-handed relief pitching.

Pirates Generating Early Spring Buzz

The Pittsburgh Pirates are attracting attention early in Spring Training. Comparisons to the 2023 Baltimore Orioles, who unexpectedly won 101 games and the AL East, highlight the Pirates’ potential. Their pitching staff, led by Paul Skenes, is a significant strength, complemented by a credible offense featuring additions like Marcell Ozuna, Brandon Lowe, and Ryan O’Hearn, alongside established players Bryan Reynolds and Oneil Cruz. Modern manager Don Kelly has also received positive reviews.