International Edition
Latest News
News

Montpellier Student Fined €500 for Face Concealment During Student Protest

An 18-year-old student was convicted of concealing his face during a student demonstration on October 13 in Montpellier, receiving a 500-euro fine from the Montpellier correctional court on Wednesday, November 18, according to Echo Des Tribunes. The ruling…

Montpellier Student Fined €500 for Face Concealment During Student Protest

An 18-year-old student was convicted of concealing his face during a student demonstration on October 13 in Montpellier, receiving a 500-euro fine from the Montpellier correctional court on Wednesday, November 18, according to Echo Des Tribunes.

The ruling delivered a split verdict for the defendant, identified in court records as Lino, an 18-year-old sales and commerce vocational student with a clean criminal record prior to the proceedings. While the court cleared him of participating in a group formed to prepare acts of violence, it upheld the charge of voluntary face concealment. Prosecutors had initially requested 140 hours of community service.

Ahead of the hearing, roughly 30 demonstrators gathered outside the courthouse following a call from Attac France to protest the legal proceedings. Lawmakers Nathalie Oziol and Ugo Bernalicis joined representatives from the Human Rights League and the Solidaires 34 union at the demonstration to voice opposition to the prosecution.

The young man also received public support from several left-wing figures, including Thomas Portes, Sylvain Carrière, Anthony Smith, Elsa Faucillon and Guillaume Meurice, as well as local collectives such as Stop Répression Lycéenne, Solidaires Étudiant·e·s Montpellier and the Quartier Généreux associative café.

Demonstration Unfolds on Comédie Square

Thousands of high school and university students marched through Montpellier on October 13. The procession started peacefully before confrontations erupted on the Place de la Comédie.

Police logs cited by the prosecutor indicate the situation deteriorated mid-initial reports, noting that while the protest initially unfolded calmly, “la situation a par la suite dégénéré,” as the public prosecutor told the Wednesday court.

Police logs recorded initial projectile throws at 15:44, stone-throwing at 16:31, and the deployment of tear gas starting at 17:09, according to Lepoing. Officers arrested the defendant at 18:25 on Rue de la Loge, holding him in police custody for 48 hours.

During the hearing, the defendant testified that he wore a shirt over his face and ski goggles solely to protect himself from tear gas. “J’ai dissimulé mon visage pour me protéger des gaz,” Lino said.

Defense counsel argued that the student lacked any intention to hide his identity, noting that according to him, “Il avait les mains nues et portait un tee-shirt parfaitement reconnaissable.” On October 13, the young man wore a blue jersey featuring a “Mélenchon 2027” slogan, which reportedly subjected him to “de nombreuses insultes.” Minutes before his trial, Lino told Infoccitanie, “On s’est fait gazer et taper.” He also said that a CRS officer threatened him with a flash-ball launcher, prompting him to back away.

Conflicting Accounts of Police Confrontation

Prosecutors presented a different narrative of the student’s actions during the unrest, pointing to police logs describing active provocation.

As the prosecutor stated, “Il avait un comportement provocateur et actif,” before citing the police operational log: “L’individu porteur du maillot Mélenchon dirige les troupes […].” Alors que la manifestation a dégénéré aux alentours de 15h45, the defendant “s’est maintenu sur les lieux, le visage dissimulé, montrant une réelle volonté de ne pas être identifié.”

Defense lawyers rejected the prosecution’s interpretation of events, arguing that the student raised his arms to calm tensions rather than incite violence. The defense requested a complete acquittal, contesting the relevance of the 140-hour community service requirement given the defendant’s daily schedule.

The court ultimately imposed the 500-euro fine but granted the defense request to exclude the conviction from the defendant’s criminal record. Supporters maintained their criticism of the prosecution, viewing the trial as an infringement on the right to demonstrate.

Court Fines Student 500 Euros for Face Concealment

Why was the defendant initially detained by police in Montpellier?

Police arrested the 18-year-old student at 18:25 on Rue de la Loge during a student march, holding him in custody for 48 hours following street clashes on Place de la Comédie.

What specific penalties did the court impose on November 18?

The Montpellier correctional court ordered the student to pay a 500-euro fine for voluntary face concealment while acquitting him of participating in a violent group, and granted a request to keep the conviction off his criminal record.

Which political figures and organizations supported the defendant outside the court?

Roughly 30 supporters gathered outside the courthouse on November 18 after an appeal by Attac France, joined by lawmakers Nathalie Oziol and Ugo Bernalicis alongside representatives from the Human Rights League and Solidaires 34, alongside public backing from Thomas Portes, Sylvain Carrière, Anthony Smith, Elsa Faucillon, Guillaume Meurice, Stop Répression Lycéenne, Solidaires Étudiant·e·s Montpellier and Quartier Généreux.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.