International Edition
Latest News
World

Myanmar Denounces ICJ Génocide Ruling as ‘Unjust’; China Echoes Criticism

Myanmar denounced the International Court of Justice ruling that found it committed genocide against the Rohingya, calling the decision “unjust” on Friday, a day after the court ordered safe repatriation and reparations for the Muslim minority. The court’s…

Myanmar Denounces ICJ Génocide Ruling as 'Unjust'; China Echoes Criticism

Myanmar denounced the International Court of Justice ruling that found it committed genocide against the Rohingya, calling the decision “unjust” on Friday, a day after the court ordered safe repatriation and reparations for the Muslim minority.

The court’s 15 judges voted 9–6 on Thursday to uphold jurisdiction and rule that Myanmar breached the Genocide Convention during its 2017 military crackdown, which forced more than 700,000 Rohingya to flee to Bangladesh. Presiding Judge Yuji Iwasawa detailed findings that security forces killed some 10,000 Rohingya, committed “widespread sexual violence” against women and inflicted “extreme violence” on children, Le Devoir reported.

“Despite the efforts deployed on our part, when one examines the result, the 15 judges were not all in agreement with the decision,” presidential spokesperson Khaing Soe told reporters in Naypyidaw on Friday, highlighting the 9–6 split, according to Tv5Monde. “I would say it is unjust,” she added, according to Le Devoir and Information.tv5monde.

ICJ ruling on Myanmar genocide: ‘Historic victory for Rohingya, landmark for international justice’ — FRANCE 24 English

China, Myanmar’s principal diplomatic backer since the 2021 coup, echoed the criticism. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun said Beijing was concerned the court “oversteps its competence and makes an expansive interpretation of practices that do not favor the settlement of disputes,” Le Devoir reported. China has maintained support for the military government led by Senior General Min Aung Hlaing while Western nations severed ties after the coup.

The ruling is binding and without appeal, but the court has no enforcement mechanism. UN General Assembly President Khalilur Rahman, who is also Bangladesh’s foreign minister, visited the sprawling Cox’s Bazar refugee camps on Friday and urged Myanmar to “bring the Rohingyas home.”

He called on Naypyidaw to fulfill its obligations “in good faith” and comply with international law, Le Devoir and Information.tv5monde reported, according to Ledevoir.

“A written judgment does not mean justice in real life; it must be followed by effect,” Rahman told thousands of refugees. He also appealed for sustained humanitarian funding, warning that UN agencies and NGOs are struggling to fill gaps left by the withdrawal of U.S. development aid decided by President Donald Trump, Le Devoir reported.

Myanmar has long rejected genocide allegations, arguing its 2017 operations were a legitimate response to insurgent attacks that killed about a dozen security personnel, Swissinfo.ch noted.

Myanmar Denounces ICJ Génocide Ruling as 'Unjust'; China Echoes Criticism
Photo: swissinfo.ch

What the court ordered

The judgment requires Myanmar to allow and facilitate the voluntary, safe and dignified return of Rohingya displaced by its actions and to provide reparations. The court also found Myanmar failed to prevent genocide and failed to punish perpetrators, obligations under the Genocide Convention.

Enforcement gap

ICJ rulings are legally binding on the parties, yet the court relies on the UN Security Council for enforcement — a body where China holds veto power.

Humanitarian stakes

More than one million Rohingya remain in crowded camps in Cox’s Bazar, dependent on international aid. Bangladesh, which is not a party to the Genocide Convention case but hosts the refugee population, has pressed for repatriation while insisting returns must be voluntary and safe. Previous bilateral repatriation attempts have failed because conflict continues in Myanmar’s Rakhine State and Rohingya refuse to return without citizenship guarantees and security.

Competing narratives

Myanmar’s military government frames the 2017 crackdown as a counter-insurgency operation triggered by attacks from the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army. The ICJ, by a 9–6 majority, concluded the response was genocidal in intent and scale.

China argues the court’s expansive reading of the convention complicates diplomatic solutions. Western states, which backed the case brought by The Gambia on behalf of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, view the ruling as a landmark affirmation of accountability.

The International Court of Justice, the UN’s principal judicial organ, was established in June 1945 and began work in April 1946 as successor to the League of Nations’ Permanent Court of International Justice. It is the only principal UN organ not based in New York, sitting instead at the Peace Palace in The Hague.

Its 15 judges are elected by the General Assembly and Security Council for nine-year terms, with no two judges sharing a nationality. The court has no enforcement power of its own; compliance ultimately depends on the Security Council, where permanent members hold vetoes.

ICJ Delivers Landmark Judgment In Rohingya Genocide Case Against Myanmar — DWS News

The next test is whether the UN General Assembly or the Security Council will take up the judgment to pressure Myanmar, and whether Bangladesh and donor nations can sustain aid levels for Rohingya refugees.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.