International Edition
Latest News
Sport

MyGolfSpy Debates Reader Proposals for Rules of Golf Changes

In a recent column for MyGolfSpy, MyGolfSpy debated reader-submitted suggestions for changing the Rules of Golf, tackling everything from fairway divots to the length of the official rulebook. The current rulebook spans 244 pages. The outlet argued that…

Golf Rules Our Readers Want Changed (And Where I Disagree)

In a recent column for MyGolfSpy, MyGolfSpy debated reader-submitted suggestions for changing the Rules of Golf, tackling everything from fairway divots to the length of the official rulebook.

The current rulebook spans 244 pages. The outlet argued that it should be trimmed down to just 10 pages to make the sport more accessible.

Several readers wrote in to challenge standard practices. Gale Nicely argued that players should receive free relief from fairway divots, noting that golfers should not be penalized for good execution.

“Hey you’ve hit the ball to its intended resting spot and shouldn’t be penalized for good execution,” Gale Nicely told MyGolfSpy.

Another reader, John Herman, questioned the complexity of the governing guidelines. He asked why the instructions are written in a way that requires advanced education to comprehend.

“Why is it that the rules of golf are explained in a manner where you need a masters degree to understand them?” John Herman told MyGolfSpy.

The debate over fairway divots revealed a deep split among players. While some advocate for treating bare divots as ground under repair, the outlet argued that establishing a workable definition for a fresh divot remains nearly impossible at both local municipal courses and professional tournaments.

Out of bounds rules also drew sharp criticism. Nat Piper suggested eliminating stroke-and-distance penalties entirely and making all property boundaries red stakes.

Michael Brown focused on the frustration of walking back to the tee when a provisional shot has not been played. Dan Salmon defended existing boundary protocols, arguing that being able to see a ball across a white stake does not change the out-of-bounds status.

The publication expressed strong opposition to white stakes, calling the severity of the penalty and the mandatory walk back to the tee excessive for modern course architectures.

Paula Fairley proposed adopting Model Local Rule B-3 permanently to allow provisional balls for shots that might be in a penalty area, which would save time on blind shots. The column agreed with this proposal, noting it as a practical adjustment for everyday rounds.

“Get rid of multiple designations for water hazards, Red vs Yellow, and make all water hazards the same penalty and option for the next shot.” — Mike said.

The report defended keeping both designations, pointing to famous designs like the island green at TPC Sawgrass No. 17 where lateral relief would drastically alter the intended design of the hole.

Other topics included flagsticks, dress codes, and round lengths.

Brent Silber defended leaving the flagstick in the cup as a helpful visual target for putters. Kyle Ericson questioned why professional players must wear long pants during hot weather when slow play remains a persistent issue. Nat Piper advocated for alternative formats, suggesting 12-hole rounds, yardage-based tee selections, and increased walking.

Founded in 2007, MyGolfSpy established itself by challenging long-standing industry testing protocols. The organization is best known for its “Most Wanted” equipment testing series, which evolved from small-scale trials into a large-scale data collection effort aimed at providing consumers with performance-based insights.

By moving away from traditional industry marketing, the outlet has focused on gathering extensive, independent data to help golfers reach their full potential without relying on conventional retail fitting methods.

About the author: Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archynewsy.