International Edition
Latest News
Health

Nationwide Protests Warn of ‘Catastrophic Collapse’ in Midwife Homebirth Access Under New Insurance Rules

"Our bodies, our babies, our births," families chanted across 26 Australian locations on Saturday, as more than 12,000 people registered to protest new insurance rules that take effect on January 1 and threaten to end most midwife-supported homebirths,…

Nationwide Protests Warn of 'Catastrophic Collapse' in Midwife Homebirth Access Under New Insurance Rules

“Our bodies, our babies, our births,” families chanted across 26 Australian locations on Saturday, as more than 12,000 people registered to protest new insurance rules that take effect on January 1 and threaten to end most midwife-supported homebirths, ABC News reported.

From the new year, a 2009 exemption that allowed privately practising midwives to attend homebirths without private professional indemnity insurance will be removed. Only midwives who hold “endorsed” registration — currently about 5 per cent of the nation’s 35,000 registered midwives, according to Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency Nursing and Midwifery Board data — can obtain the necessary cover, leaving the vast majority unable to legally practise in home settings.

Advocates warn of forced freebirths and regional crisis

Homebirth Australia coordinator Katelyn Commerford said the change will drive women toward freebirth — giving birth without any medical professional present — particularly in regional areas where hospitals can be hours away.

Homebirth rallies against new insurance rules — ABC News (Australia)

“Some women are choosing homebirths because their local hospital might be three hours drive away,” Commerford told ABC News. “You’ve got women who are going to end up birthing on the side of the road of a national highway with trucks flying past them on the phone to a Triple Zero operator that’s never even seen a birth before.”

In Geraldton, Western Australia, Cath Tan said she is the only privately practising endorsed midwife north of Perth offering homebirths. “There’s no access here at all … it’s definitely not fair,” she told ABC News. Fellow Geraldton midwife Jaimee Shannon called for a regional exemption: “This change is ridiculous. Give us an exemption in regional and remote areas.”

Silhouette of a construction crane against a colorful urban sunset
Photo: realtimeainews.com

In Esperance, Kirsten Dobbs, the sole endorsed midwife providing homebirth services, rejected safety justifications for the rule. “One in three women come out of hospital with birth trauma, so don’t talk to me about safety,” she said at the local rally.

Wagga mother Marnie Butt said the two endorsed midwives in her Riverina region fill quickly. “We’ve only got two endorsed midwives here locally [so] their capacity fills really quickly,” she told ABC News.

Protests erupt across Australia as homebirth access comes under threat — 9 News Australia

Insurance product exists but deemed unworkable

Federal Health Minister Mark Butler defended the change, saying an insurance product has been developed and offered to midwives. “Particularly [when] delivering services like birthing, given the huge consequences in those rare circumstances where things go wrong,” he told ABC News this week, calling insurance a “no-brainer” for all health practitioners. Health ministers across the country agreed 18 months ago to bring homebirth midwives into line with other practitioners.

The Australian College of Midwives and frontline practitioners say the available product does not solve the problem. Australian College of Midwives President Ali Teate agreed the government had not developed an appropriate insurance policy. Ali Teate at the homebirth rally in Glenelg.

Better Births Illawarra co-founder Sharon Settecasse warned at the Wollongong rally: “We’re worried that babies and mothers are going to die if this exemption doesn’t get extended.” Queensland Nurses and Midwives Union assistant secretary Fridae King echoed the call for a reliable insurance solution at the Brisbane rally.

Australia homebirth rules leave just 5% of midwives eligible — Australia Today

Endorsed midwife calls for working group

Endorsed midwife Helena Ruane urged the government to establish a working group to find a “permanent and affordable insurance solution.” Speaking at the Sydney rally, Ruane said: “Today isn’t simply about insurance … it’s about human rights.”

Darwin mother-to-be Jessica, who had planned a homebirth for months, said she would likely abandon her plans and had considered freebirth. “I understand the risks with it … but I [can’t] pretend it hasn’t crossed my mind,” she told ABC News. “That’s how terrified I am of being forced to give birth at a hospital.”

Current rules require two midwives

Under Australian law, a planned homebirth legally requires two midwives. The first must be endorsed, but the supporting second midwife does not currently need endorsement — a distinction the rule change effectively removes for private practitioners.

Families and advocates are warning of a “catastrophic collapse” in access to midwife-supported homebirths, as thousands rally across the country protesting new insurance rules.

The temporary exemption allowing registered midwives to attend homebirths without indemnity insurance was first established in 2009.

In the Riverina region, Wagga mother Marnie Butt said there were not enough endorsed midwives to support the amount of people wanting homebirths.

Exemption lapses January 1 as advocates seek extension

The exemption lapses on January 1. Advocates are calling for an extension while a workable insurance framework is negotiated. Dr Teate told the Glenelg rally the college wants women to access insured midwives but said the current pathway creates unsustainable barriers for practitioners.

About the author: Health Desk

Health Desk at Archynewsy.