International Edition
Latest News
Sport

NHL Goalies Face Mental Health Crisis Amid Isolation and Pressure

“I can’t do this. I can’t do anything,” Linus Ullmark thought in January 2026 as panic gripped him during a game against the Toronto Maple Leafs. The 32-year-old Ottawa Senators goaltender surrendered an early goal before his heart…

“I can’t do this. I can’t do anything,” Linus Ullmark thought in January 2026 as panic gripped him during a game against the Toronto Maple Leafs.

The 32-year-old Ottawa Senators goaltender surrendered an early goal before his heart raced and his lungs heaved, prompting team physicians to try breathing exercises in the medical room. Ullmark returned to the ice, but after allowing four goals on 14 shots, his coach pulled him and he left the team the next day.

Ullmark’s departure highlights a broader mental health crisis sweeping through the National Hockey League crease. The solitary nature of the position, intense all-or-nothing dynamics, and pervasive social media criticism have pushed professional netminders to a breaking point.

Nearly a third of all players publicly known to have entered the NHL/NHLPA player assistance program or taken a leave for mental health since 2016 have been goaltenders, a position representing just 10 percent of the league. Players including Carey Price, Spencer Knight, Robin Lehner, Connor Ingram, and Jack Campbell have faced anxiety, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and depression.

Oilers cycle through goalies amid scrutiny

The crisis finds a notable epicenter in Edmonton, where the Oilers have cycled through starting netminders under intense scrutiny. Mikko Koskinen expressed frustration during the 2021-22 season over being thrown under the bus in a market where everything is under a microscope.

Two years ago, the Oilers bought out struggling goaltender Jack Campbell after signing him to a five-year contract in 2022. Campbell later entered the player assistance program and received a diagnosis of anxiety and OCD.

Last season, the Oilers traded Stuart Skinner after a run of poor play, while Connor Ingram went unsigned this summer and retired at 29 despite posting decent numbers. Skinner’s wife noted how online death threats impacted their family.

Isolation inside the crease

Goaltenders face unique psychological demands that set them apart from skaters and players in other major team sports. Bob Knauz, a psychologist who works with the Boston Bruins, noted the extreme isolation of the role.

“With goalies, there’s really only one,” Knauz said, contrasting the single netminder with groups of 12 forwards and six defensemen on the ice.

Unlike soccer goalkeepers who face far fewer shots, NHL goaltenders operate inside a chaotic environment with pucks deflecting constantly and opponents blocking their line of sight. Bill Ranford, who won the Conn Smythe Trophy with the Oilers in 1990, summarized the precarious dynamic.

“The goalie is either the hero or the goat, and there is nothing in between,” Ranford said.

Goalies face anxiety from past to present

Private terrors have afflicted netminders for nearly a century, from Chicago’s Charlie Gardiner overcoming anxiety before his 1927 debut to Montreal’s Bill Durnan suffering from anxiety and insomnia in 1950. Modern players often rely on obsessive rituals and routines to maintain control in an uncontrollable environment.

Brian Shaw, a sports psychologist and co-director of the player assistance program for nearly three decades, explained the danger of those obsessive habits.

“At its worst, it takes over — and then it’s overwhelming,” Shaw said.

Corey Hirsch experienced deep, repetitive thoughts and panic attacks as a 21-year-old third-string goalie with the New York Rangers in 1994. The intrusive thoughts became a constant fight on the ice.

“You love it so much you hyperfocus on it,” Hirsch said.

While more players have started to speak out, sports psychiatrist Dr. Carla Edwards warns that honesty can carry professional consequences. Edwards said that teams often discard players as soon as vulnerability is identified.

“I’ve seen in many teams that I’ve worked with, as soon as someone is identified as being a potential vulnerability, they’re gone,” Edwards said.

Goaltender mental health questions

Which goaltenders have spoken publicly about mental health struggles?

Players including Linus Ullmark, Jack Campbell, Robin Lehner, Spencer Knight, and Michael DiPietro have discussed their battles with anxiety, OCD, and depression.

What percentage of player assistance entries involve goalies?

Since 2016, nearly a third of all players known to have entered the NHL/NHLPA player assistance program or taken a leave for mental health support have been goaltenders, despite the position making up only 10 percent of the league.

Why do goalies face higher mental health risks than skaters?

The position is uniquely isolating, requiring players to operate entirely on their own while reacting to constant, unpredictable scoring chances without control over defensive play in front of them.

The National Hockey League, founded in Montreal on November 26, 1917, after the suspension of its predecessor, the National Hockey Association, began with four Canadian teams and expanded to the United States in 1924 with the Boston Bruins.

For 25 seasons, from 1942 to 1967, the league consisted of only six teams, known as the “Original Six,” before a series of expansions brought the total to 32 franchises, 25 in the United States and 7 in Canada. The league has awarded the Stanley Cup, the oldest professional sports trophy in North America, to its playoff champion since 1926.

“No one really knows what we’re going through as an NHL goalie unless you talk to another NHL goalie,” Campbell told The Athletic.

About the author: Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archynewsy.