“It sends a very clear message to students of color and faculty and staff that racism is welcome here,” said Amanda Gorman, an American poet studying at Oxford.
An Oxford University college became the center of a free speech controversy on Tuesday as hundreds of protesters demonstrated against an event featuring academic Nathan Cofnas, Audacy reported. Activists tried to block entry to Oriel College while holding placards reading “Far right off campus” and “Remember Professor Jason Arday”, according to The Independent. Protesters placed a Ku Klux Klan hood and a sign reading “Racists welcome here” on the college’s statue of 19th-century imperialist Cecil Rhodes.
Cofnas spoke to about two dozen people inside the college using a microphone to project his voice over outside chants of “Shut him down”, according to usnews.com. He argued that diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts rest on a false premise and that racial groups do not share equal potential, the student newspaper Cherwell reported.
Backlash Over Meritocracy Claims and Plagiarism Accusations
The speaker raised his profile earlier this year by accusing the late Cambridge professor Jason Arday of plagiarism in his doctoral thesis, The Independent reported. Arday was found dead at his London apartment in August at age 41 following intense media scrutiny, Audacy reported. More than 30,000 people signed an online petition backed by Stand Up to Racism demanding that the university deny him a platform, Audacy reported.
“In 2026, Oxford University will give a platform to a eugenicist,” a Labour lawmaker complained during parliamentary discussions, usnews.com reported. Lawmaker Bell Ribeiro-Addy added that “Free speech sits alongside equality law, not above it, and little thought seems to have been given to Oxford’s Black students,” Audacy reported.
College Defends Hosting Event
Oriel College stated on its website that hosting the event did not mean the institution endorsed the speaker’s views, Audacy reported. The Oxford Universities’ Reform Society, which organized the gathering, emphasized that its own committee made the decision while the college merely complied with free speech laws, usnews.com reported. The group said it seeks to “rebalance” representation at Oxford and described Cofnas as “repeatedly victimized.” Its statement said the group is “committed to broadening participation in university life by removing systemic barriers for marginalized voices.”
Cambridge University terminated Cofnas as a philosophy researcher in 2024 after his critique of DEI programs triggered campus protests, usnews.com reported.
Cambridge University said last year that an inquiry concluded that “while seen by many as offensive,” Cofnas’ views “did not breach the law and did not contravene University regulations designed to uphold free speech.” He subsequently secured a postdoctoral position at Ghent University in Belgium this year, but faced suspension following the media storm surrounding Arday, Audacy reported.
Writing in The Wall Street Journal in August, Cofnas maintained that he was wrongly accused of racism and misunderstood, usnews.com reported. He said that he merely cited Harvard’s findings when calculating undergraduate representation under a colorblind system. “But it’s a difficult fact to face that in a truly colorblind system that didn’t take race into account, there would be a shocking lack of diversity in certain institutions.”
Questions Regarding the Oxford Free Speech Controversy
Who organized the event at Oriel College?
The Oxford Universities’ Reform Society organized the talk, emphasizing that its committee made the decision independently rather than the college or the wider University of Oxford, Audacy reported.
What specific plagiarism claims surrounded Jason Arday?
Nathan Cofnas targeted Arday in a blog post alleging plagiarism within his doctoral thesis, The Independent reported. Arday was found dead at his south London apartment in August at age 41, Audacy reported.

How did Cambridge University handle Cofnas previously?
Cambridge terminated the position of Cofnas, a philosophy researcher, in 2024 after his critique of diversity programs sparked campus protests, usnews.com reported.
Keep reading