Mark J. Longo Jr., the former owner of the internet-famous squirrel Peanut, was arrested on Wednesday on charges of grand larceny and mortgage fraud following an investigation by New York State Police.
Investigators allege that Longo used falsified pay stubs, letters, and mortgage application documents to secure a $720,000 residential mortgage, according to a state police news release cited by syracuse.com. As gothamist.com noted, this figure is identical to the proceeds Longo and two partners obtained in 2023 for a Chemung County site that was later transformed into the 311-acre P’Nut’s Freedom Farm Animal Sanctuary.
The felony charges brought against Longo include two counts of fourth-degree conspiracy, eight counts of first-degree falsifying business records, second-degree attempted grand larceny, second-degree attempted residential mortgage fraud, and second-degree residential mortgage fraud. He was arraigned in Southport Town Court, pleaded not guilty, and was released on his own recognizance, according to state police.

The 36-year-old Pine City resident built a large social media following by documenting the antics of Peanut, a squirrel he cared for alongside a raccoon named Fred. The animals gained national attention in 2024 after state Department of Environmental Conservation officials euthanized them for rabies testing following a bite during a home raid. The tests returned negative results.
State police stated they began investigating Longo in December 2024 after receiving information regarding alleged financial irregularities. Investigators conducted interviews, executed search warrants, and reviewed financial records before making the arrest on Wednesday.
Longo’s wife, Daniela Bittner, was taken into custody by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Oct. 16, according to statements Longo provided to the New York Post and TMZ. Bittner, a 30-year-old German native who married Longo in 2022, faces possible deportation, which Longo attributed to a paperwork issue.
Peanut’s death previously sparked widespread public backlash and violent threats against the Department of Environmental Conservation and its staff. The agency reported receiving numerous bomb threats that temporarily closed about 10 buildings and forced its workforce of roughly 3,000 employees to work remotely.
P’Nut’s Freedom Farm Animal Sanctuary, a registered 501(c)(3) nonprofit in Pine City, New York, was inspired by the orphaned squirrel whose death prompted the public outcry.
The 311-acre operation provides refuge for horses, alpacas, pigs, sheep, dogs, cats, bunnies and rehabilitating wildlife under the motto “Where Second Chances Spark New Beginnings.” It relies on donations, sponsorships such as engraved Legacy Path bricks, and community support to care for and rehome animals facing hardship.
Longo did not immediately respond to a request for comment, gothamist.com reported. He is scheduled to return to Southport Town Court on Feb. 4.