Pet owners facing rising insurance premiums should compare the full scope of new policies against their existing coverage before switching providers. While a lower monthly rate may appear attractive, new plans often exclude pre-existing conditions, reset waiting periods, and offer different reimbursement levels that could lead to higher out-of-pocket costs during a medical crisis.
Weighing Pre-existing Condition Exclusions
The biggest risk when switching pet insurance providers is losing coverage for chronic health issues. A new insurer typically classifies any condition diagnosed before the start of a new policy as pre-existing, which means they will not pay for related treatments, CBS News reported.
Even if a pet’s condition—such as arthritis, allergies, or diabetes—was covered under an existing plan, a new provider is under no obligation to continue that coverage. According to Pets Best, this loss of protection can be permanent, leaving owners responsible for the entirety of future veterinary bills for those specific ailments.
Premium Savings Often Require Higher Deductibles and Lower Reimbursement
A cheaper monthly quote does not always translate to lower long-term costs. Pet insurance plans frequently differ in their structural components, and switching to a lower premium often requires accepting less favorable terms.

| Feature | Cost-Saving Tradeoff |
|---|---|
| Deductible | May increase from $500 to $1,000 |
| Reimbursement | May drop from 90% to 70% |
| Monthly Premium | Potential savings of $15 to $20 |
When evaluating these differences, owners should look at the annual premium alongside the deductible and reimbursement rate, CBS News noted. A policy with a lower premium might leave a pet owner paying substantially more after a major accident or illness due to higher deductibles or lower annual coverage caps.
Switching Insurers Creates Waiting Periods and Coverage Gaps
Switching companies triggers new waiting periods before coverage for illnesses or accidents takes effect. During this time, any new health issues that arise are generally ineligible for reimbursement, Pets Best reported.
There is also the danger of a coverage gap if a current policy is canceled before a new one is fully active. If a pet becomes injured during this transition, the owner likely assumes full financial responsibility for the veterinary care.
Adjusting Current Policy Terms
Before abandoning a long-standing provider, owners can ask their current insurer about options to reduce premiums without switching companies. Increasing the deductible or lowering the reimbursement percentage can often lower the monthly cost while maintaining coverage for major incidents, CBS News reported.
“An increase doesn’t necessarily mean you’re paying too much; it may simply reflect the increasing cost of providing veterinary care,” Pets Best said. Some insurers may also allow policyholders to adjust annual coverage limits if the current threshold is higher than necessary for their specific needs.
Pets Best traces its roots to 1981, when Dr. Jack Stephens launched North America’s first pet insurance policy, later issuing the inaugural policy to the celebrity dog Lassie in 1982.
The company itself was founded in 2005 in Boise, Idaho, by Stephens and Greg McDonald, and Stephens co-founded the North American Pet Health Insurance Association in 2008. Pets Best became the first insurer to offer fully electronic claim filing and payment in 2011 and has paid $1.3 billion in covered claims while insuring more than 1 million pets.
Assessing Medical History Impact
The decision to switch is often more straightforward for owners of young, healthy pets with minimal medical history, as there are fewer concerns regarding pre-existing condition exclusions. For older pets or those with chronic conditions, the value of an established policy—which covers ongoing health problems—may far outweigh the potential savings of a lower monthly premium, CBS News reported.
It remains unclear how many pet owners successfully lower their total annual costs by switching versus those who inadvertently increase their financial exposure through reduced coverage terms. Whether insurers will introduce more flexible, tiered premium options to retain customers facing budget pressures is not yet known.