International Edition
Latest News
News

Retired Operator Allen Cherry: TWU Local 100 Missed Strike Chance as Subway Contract Expired

Retired transit operator Allen Cherry says the Transport Workers Union Local 100 missed a chance to strike alongside Long Island Rail Road unions on May 16, 2024, when the subway contract expired, World Socialist Web Site reported. Cherry,…

Retired Operator Allen Cherry: TWU Local 100 Missed Strike Chance as Subway Contract Expired

Retired transit operator Allen Cherry says the Transport Workers Union Local 100 missed a chance to strike alongside Long Island Rail Road unions on May 16, 2024, when the subway contract expired, World Socialist Web Site reported.

Cherry, a 27-year veteran of New York City Transit and a member of the Socialist Equality Party, said the Taylor Law’s two-for-one penalty — a day’s pay lost plus a day’s pay fined for each strike day — has been used by union officials to block job actions. “Any fighting leadership would have struck on May 16, when the subway contract expired on the exact same day that five Long Island Rail Road unions walked out,” Cherry told World Socialist Web Site. “It was a prime opportunity for unified action, but the TWU bureaucracy refused to violate the Taylor Law.”

The interview comes as Mayor Zohran Mamdani, a Democratic Socialists of America member, challenges a City Council bill granting a one-time $10,000 bonus to low-paid Department of Education paraprofessionals. Mamdani argues any raise must be negotiated under the Taylor Law.

Cherry said the mayor is using the statute to repress workers. “Despite calling himself a socialist, Mamdani is acting as an enemy of the working class and socialism,” Cherry said. “The capitalist class relies on pseudo-socialists like the DSA to trap working-class anger within the political establishment.”

Taylor Law history shapes current contract fight

Enacted in 1967 after the Condon-Wadlin Act failed to stop a 1966 transit strike led by TWU President Mike Quill, the Taylor Law granted collective bargaining and automatic dues checkoff in exchange for a strike ban, the two-for-one fine on workers, and threats to the union treasury and dues checkoff if a walkout occurred. Cherry said the dues-checkoff penalty was “deliberately designed to turn the union apparatus into the state’s policeman on the job.”

Transit workers have labored without a contract since May 16. Cherry said inflation has eroded real wages while the MTA demands steeper givebacks. After the 2005 strike, the union accepted a 1.5 percent wage deduction for health benefits that later rose to 2 percent. “Once you accept concessions, you open the door to larger ones,” Cherry said.

Cherry started as a conductor in July 1982, two years after the 11-day 1980 transit strike that the TWU leadership called off in what he called a sellout. One year earlier, Ronald Reagan fired more than 11,000 striking PATCO air traffic controllers. The AFL-CIO rejected calls for a general strike, a decision Cherry said “launched a decade of union-busting” at Phelps Dodge, Greyhound, Hormel, Wheeling-Pittsburgh, the airlines, and in the coalfields.

In New York, municipal union leaders had used pension funds in 1975 to bail out the city, subordinating workers to the Municipal Assistance Corporation. By 1982, Cherry said workers were “discouraged, angry and constantly asking, ‘Where is the union? What is it doing for us?’” Local 100 officials coached members to say the union was “here doing a great job,” but workers used the word “union” as an insult.

Ed Winn, a bus mechanic at East New York depot and Workers League leader, was elected to the Local 100 Executive Board and voted against the 1980 settlement. Cherry described Winn as “perhaps the most politically advanced worker in the country.” Winn connected shop-floor defense to a break with the capitalist parties.

“You have to be a good worker, show up on time, and deny management any easy pretext to victimize you — and you have to fight for a political alternative, for socialism,” Winn told a coworker facing discipline, according to Cherry.

Winn ran as the Workers League candidate for U.S. president in 1984 and 1988. He died in 1995.

Cherry won board seats as socialist

Before completing his probationary year, Cherry ran as an independent socialist for the Local 100 Executive Board in Rapid Transit Operations, winning roughly 25 percent of the vote among conductors. He later won about a quarter of the vote running for chairman of the motormen’s division. “Workers didn’t necessarily agree with our entire program, but they backed someone who stood up to management and the bureaucracy,” Cherry said.

From 1982 through the late 1990s, Cherry sold The Bulletin and later the International Workers Bulletin in crew rooms. Management posted notices banning literature sales; someone scrawled “Alan Cherry and Edwin Soto” beneath the order.

Soto, who joined the Trotskyist movement as a teenager, worked in the subway system for more than three decades before retiring in 2020.

Daily rules were draconian. Calling in sick triggered home visits by inspectors; stepping out for medicine required calling control. Bathroom breaks at terminals needed dispatcher permission.

At Stillwell Avenue in Brooklyn, supervisors stood outside restrooms with clipboards logging workers’ names. “The disciplinary system operated on a presumption of guilt, and at hearings, union reps rarely mounted a real defense — I usually had to argue my own cases,” Cherry said.

The “New Directions” caucus, founded in part by Steve Downs — a member of Cherry’s 1982 conductor class and a former member of the group Solidarity — won Local 100 leadership under Roger Toussaint in 2000. Cherry called it “an opportunist caucus of middle-class radicals and careerists who exploited the anger of younger workers.”

Downs later endorsed Barack Obama for president.

During the 1999–2000 contract dispute, workers held bargaining power ahead of the Times Square millennial celebrations. Mayor Rudy Giuliani obtained a court injunction imposing fines of $25,000 per worker on the first day, doubling each subsequent day. Cherry said the bureaucracy’s collusion with the state was “blatant.”

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.