International Edition
Latest News
World

Romanian Lawyer Barred from ECHR for Two Years Over AI-Hallucinated Cases

A Romanian lawyer was barred on Friday from representing litigants before the European Court of Human Rights for two years due to unverified artificial intelligence citations. The President of the Court, Mattias Guyomar, approved a reasoned proposal from…

Romanian Lawyer Barred from ECHR for Two Years Over AI-Hallucinated Cases

A Romanian lawyer was barred on Friday from representing litigants before the European Court of Human Rights for two years due to unverified artificial intelligence citations.

The President of the Court, Mattias Guyomar, approved a reasoned proposal from a court chamber to exclude the advocate, as reported by The Irish Times. The disciplinary action stems from observations submitted in a pending case where the practitioner served as one of two representatives for an applicant, leaving the second representative unaffected by the ruling.

Court examiners found that the filings contained a pattern of repeated substantive errors rather than isolated mistakes.

These flaws involved references to nonexistent hallucinated cases, citations of fictitious paragraphs in genuine judgments, and the inclusion of existing case law that either contradicted the arguments or proved entirely irrelevant.

“[The] submissions contained a pattern of numerous, repeated substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes,” the chamber said in its findings, concluding that the conduct fell short of professional and ethical duties.

Professional Duties and AI Use

The lawyer acknowledged using artificial intelligence tools to draft the court observations, characterizing the mistakes as inaccuracies and citation errors. Under the Legal Profession Act and relevant court rules, advocates carry a strict duty to act as reasonably competent professionals displaying a high level of professional prudence.

The chamber determined that this obligation required the representative to independently check all case law and arguments generated by artificial intelligence against authoritative databases prior to filing.

Investigators said that the practitioner failed to conduct even rudimentary checks, as many errors were repetitive and easily detectable through a cursory database search.

“[No] checks were carried out in respect of certain case-law references,” the chamber said, adding that the admission of insufficient review was a major understatement.

Impact on the Court

The unverified filings caused tangible prejudice to the administration of justice by forcing the court to spend considerable time verifying observations, initiating formal proceedings, and corresponding extensively with stakeholders. This administrative burden diverted resources away from the court’s core functions under the European Convention on Human Rights, meeting the exceptional circumstances threshold required for a formal exclusion.

The chamber invited comments from the lawyer, the Romanian government, and the Romanian National Bar Association before reaching its decision. While the ruling suspends the advocate’s right of representation for two years, the decision does not preclude the possibility of those rights being restored in the future.

Mattias Guyomar, born in Guérande, France, in 1968, built a career in French administrative law before joining the Strasbourg court. He entered the Conseil d’État in 1996 and later presided over its 10th Chamber.

He also served as Secretary-General of the French Electoral Commission for over two decades. Elected as the judge in respect of France in June 2020, he became President of a Section in May 2024 and assumed the Court presidency on 30 May 2025.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.