New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani faces mounting calls from prominent political figures to skip upcoming 9/11 memorial ceremonies marking the 25th anniversary of the terror attacks. Former Mayor Rudy Giuliani and former New York Governor George Pataki have both publicly argued that Mamdani should stay away from the site, citing his associations with controversial figures who have criticized United States foreign policy.
Giuliani and Pataki Demand Mayor Stay Away
The Former Mayor Calls Attendance an Offense
According to an interview with Newsmax on Sunday, Rudy Giuliani stated that the mayor’s attendance “offends me.” Giuliani, who led New York City through the September 11, 2001 attacks, argued that the anniversary ceremonies are for the families and for America to remember historically. Giuliani asserted that Mamdani has associated with individuals who hold extreme views against the United States.
Pataki Demands Rejection of Extremist Views
Former New York Governor George Pataki echoed those sentiments in an interview with City and State on Thursday. Pataki argued that anyone who does not intentionally distance themselves from figures like Twitch streamer Hasan Piker—who previously commented that America deserved the attacks—should not be present at the memorial site. Pataki stated that Mamdani has two choices: reject extremist views or voluntarily decide his presence is not in the best interest of the victims’ families.
Online Petition Nears 100,000 Signatures
Despite the criticism from former city and state leaders, Mayor Mamdani has maintained that he will attend the memorial services this week. The debate over his attendance has drawn mixed reactions across the political spectrum, alongside an online petition opposing his presence that has gathered nearly 100,000 signatures.
Governor Hochul Defends the Mayor’s Rightful Place
New York Governor Kathy Hochul strongly disagreed with the calls for Mamdani to stay home. Speaking on the matter, Hochul argued that the mayor failing to show up would be a significant slight to the families of victims who do not oppose his attendance. Hochul emphasized that Mamdani serves as the sitting mayor of New York City and belongs at the official commemorative events.
Related reading