Rugby concussion claimants face an anxious wait to see if their landmark legal action will be struck out after a two-day hearing at the Royal Courts of Justice failed to reach a conclusion.
The Telegraph reported that KP Law is fighting to save the first batch of 378 cases in the union action after missing a crucial deadline for disclosing medical documents.
Judges Mr Justice Cotter and Senior Master Cook will deliver a judgment on the strike-out application later this year. Whichever side loses the upcoming verdict is expected to appeal the decision, dragging the protracted legal battle out even further.
Paul Downes KC, representing the claimants, told the court that his firm inherited a “shambolic” state of affairs from previous representation Rylands Garth. Downes revealed that they have only secured medical letters of diagnosis from 36 players in the union case. He also claimed that Richard Boardman, the solicitor removed from the record in August, failed to co-operate with transferring medical files unless he received payment.
KP Law argued for another extension running through to January, with Downes claiming that “more has been achieved in 99 days than in the previous three years” regarding the supply of medical documentation. World Cup winners Steve Thompson and Phil Vickery are among the high-profile claimants represented in the litigation.
Rugby Authorities Demand Finality
Legal counsel for rugby’s governing bodies strongly opposed any further delays, arguing that no material change in circumstances justifies extending deadlines two years, two weeks, and five days after the initial cutoff passed. William Audland KC, representing the Rugby Football League, questioned the endless cycle of missed deadlines during the proceedings.

“When does this stop?” William Audland KC said, according to The Telegraph. “There never does seem to be an end to this problem because of the mess they got themselves into in the first place. Millions of pounds have been spent and wasted, when does this stop? If this isn’t the occasion when the court says ‘no’, when will we ever get there?”
Audland added that any subsequent deadline would likely come and go with further non-compliance.
Meanwhile, Nina Goolamali KC, representing World Rugby, challenged KP Law’s assertion that they inherited the case completely blind to the administrative chaos. Goolamali pointed out that the firm was aware that consultant firm Leigh Day estimated it would require four months of intensive due diligence just to comprehend the case’s complexities, leading Leigh Day to decline taking it on.
Instead, the litigation was picked up by KP Law, which is owned by Asertis, the litigation funder that previously underwrote Rylands Garth’s work. Michael Kent KC, representing the Rugby Football Union, described the move as a final desperate gamble by the funder.
“This may be a situation where Asertis and KP Law, having run out of options because they couldn’t get Leigh Day to come on board, decided, ‘Well, let’s have one last throw of the dice’ and bring on our ‘in-house’ team,” Michael Kent KC said.
Defence lawyers also dismissed KP Law’s targeted trial date of October 2028 as completely impossible. The Telegraph revealed that former solicitor Boardman is facing a lawsuit from his own barrister over allegations of improper payments made to his wife.
Union cases risk strike-out over missed deadlines
Why are the 378 union cases at risk of being struck out?
The first batch of 378 cases faces a strike-out because the claimants missed mandatory deadlines for disclosing vital medical documents and diagnostic letters.
Who are the legal representatives for the governing bodies?
William Audland KC represents the Rugby Football League, Nina Goolamali KC represents World Rugby, and Michael Kent KC represents the Rugby Football Union.
What is the status of the trial timeline?
KP Law has targeted a trial date of October 2028, but defense lawyers have dismissed that schedule as impossible.
The Rugby Football League, representing the 13-a-side code, was founded in 1895 as the Northern Rugby Football Union after 22 clubs resigned from the Rugby Football Union over broken-time payments. It adopted its current name in 1922 and organised the first Rugby League World Cup in 1954, which Great Britain won. Based in Manchester, the RFL administers the England national team and the professional Super League competition introduced in 1996.
Judges Mr Justice Cotter and Senior Master Cook will deliver a judgment this year.
Related reading