“Deliberate anti-competitive attack,” Ryanair chief executive Michael O’Leary said, describing an ownership dispute brought against the airline at the High Court’s big-business division, The Irish Times reported.
Last month, proceedings from an Amsterdam-registered trade association called European Network Airlines Association (ENAA) against the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) were admitted to the fast-track Commercial Court, with Ryanair acting as a notice party. The ENAA claims that Ryanair fails to comply with EU ownership requirements under air-services regulations.
These rules state that no more than 50 percent of relevant equity share capital can be owned by EU nationals. Ryanair maintains it complies fully because restrictions on non-EU shareholders strip them of voting, attendance, and speaking rights at annual general meetings.
Judge Eileen Roberts refused an application from barrister Shane Cranley to join Lufthansa, KLM, and Air France as named parties in the lawsuit on Monday. The judge said that adding these individual airlines would needlessly complicate proceedings that need to follow an established timetable. However, the judge allowed the airlines to submit affidavits on their behalf during the ongoing legal arguments.
In an official affidavit responding to the court challenge, O’Leary argued that the ENAA action was instigated by a limited number of members, specifically Lufthansa and Air France. He claimed the suit is a deliberate attempt to ground an airline whose lower fares competitors cannot match.
“[T]he applicant’s members [are] (namely Lufthansa and Air France) in an attempt to ground an airline whose lower fares they cannot match,” O’Leary said in his affidavit, according to The Irish Times.
O’Leary said that the ENAA aims to reduce the ability of European airlines to access non-EU capital down to the lowest possible level under bilateral air-service agreements with India. He suggested the lawsuit serves as retaliation against Ryanair for highlighting years of illegal state aid received by those specific member airlines.
The Ryanair chief executive told the court he had not known the ENAA existed until it launched unfounded allegations against his airline. He asserted that the association is controlled by Air France-KLM and Lufthansa, which he described as two of Europe’s highest-fare flag-carrier airlines.
The ENAA’s members also belong to Airlines for Europe (A4E), the primary trade association representing most major European airlines. O’Leary said that the ENAA’s position on air services regulations directly contradicts the collective stance of A4E.
“Withdraw from the proceedings or else from A4E,” O’Leary warned ENAA members, adding that failure to do so would leave Ryanair with no choice but to exit the larger trade group.
The ENAA claims that Ryanair violates EU air-services regulations requiring that no more than 50 percent of an airline’s relevant equity share capital belongs to EU nationals.
Ryanair argues it complies with regulations because restrictions prevent non-EU shareholders from exercising voting, attendance, or speaking rights at annual general meetings.
Ryanair’s chief executive alleges that Lufthansa and Air France instigated the ENAA lawsuit as an anti-competitive attack to target lower-cost competition and retaliate for Ryanair pointing out past state aid.
Related reading