The Securities and Exchange Commission is considering a proposal to rescind its rule restricting investment advisers from making political contributions to officials who influence the selection of managers for public pension funds.
The potential move has triggered a divide between the financial services industry, which argues the rule is flawed, and pension fund leaders who warn of a return to corruption.
Financial services firms maintain the regulation has caused unintended consequences and is fundamentally misguided, according to reporting by Pensions & Investments.
The industry is pushing for the SEC to abandon the restriction, arguing that existing federal and state laws already provide adequate oversight.
Conversely, pension fund leaders are urging the SEC to maintain the current framework. They argue that repealing the rule would invite governance headaches and create an environment susceptible to pay-to-play scandals, Pensions & Investments reported.
The current SEC rule serves as a federal backstop, limiting an adviser’s ability to influence the awarding of public investment contracts through campaign donations. The Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) submitted a comment to the SEC, arguing that removing this protection would dismantle a critical barrier against corruption.
“The SEC should abandon its proposal to rescind its political contribution rule which restricts investment advisers from giving to public officials who have influence over choosing the investment advisers who will manage public pension funds,” CREW said in its filing.
The debate centers on whether the rule is still necessary. While the SEC has not brought an enforcement action related to pay-to-play schemes since the rule’s compliance date, CREW suggests this absence of litigation could support the idea that the rule is successful, rather than a sign that it is redundant.
The SEC has expressed conflicting statements about the effectiveness of the political contribution rule. SEC Chairman Atkins has argued that matters of political contributions are more appropriately managed by state and local laws, rather than federal mandates, according to CREW.
The agency has also said that rescinding the rule could lead to a “collective action” problem.
Under such a scenario, government officials might feel pressured to accept contributions to remain competitive, while advisers might feel compelled to donate simply to avoid being overlooked, CREW reported.
While the SEC acknowledges these concerns, it has also pointed to potential savings from the rule’s rescission that could go toward establishing more efficient and profitable funds.
If the SEC removes its federal standard, responsibility would return to a compliance system that varies from state to state. Some jurisdictions have no restrictions on political contributions, potentially leaving public pension funds vulnerable to the influence of donors. The proposal follows a signal from the Trump administration of an intention to ease access to private equity in 401(k)s.
This shift has amplified fears that states and municipalities might entrust public pension funds with whoever gives the biggest donation, potentially eroding public trust in government officials and the individuals chosen to manage funds.
The SEC has not yet set a final date for a vote on the rescission. The question remains whether the agency will move to dismantle the federal standard despite the warnings from pension fund overseers and ethics advocates.