International Edition
Latest News
World

Small Town Murder Examines Murphys, California Case in New Episode ‘Burning Desire For Murder

Apple Podcasts released a new episode of Small Town Murder examining a Murphys, California case in which a man faces suspicion after two family members die in unusual circumstances, according to the platform’s listing published November 19, 2026.…

Small Town Murder Examines Murphys, California Case in New Episode 'Burning Desire For Murder

Apple Podcasts released a new episode of Small Town Murder examining a Murphys, California case in which a man faces suspicion after two family members die in unusual circumstances, according to the platform’s listing published November 19, 2026.

The three‑hour, nine‑minute installment, titled “Burning Desire For Murder,” carries an explicit‑content restriction and is unavailable for web streaming in some regions, Apple’s directory shows. Listeners must sign in to access the episode, which asks whether the suspect is “the unluckiest person alive or a cold‑blooded murderer” and whether any proof exists to secure a conviction.

Hosts James Petrigallo and Jimmy Witsman open the show by describing the story as “a real weird story with a real strange guy,” then promote their Patreon feed, which they say unlocks nearly 400 ad‑free bonus episodes across Small Town Murder and sister show Crime in Sports, podscripts.co reported.

The duo also preview a forthcoming Patreon‑only episode on the 2015‑2017 “clown panic” phenomenon, coinciding with a new documentary titled Clown Panic.

Petrigallo and Witsman frame the program as a comedy show built on verified research. “We don’t make anything up for comedic effect or anything crazy like that,” Petrigallo said on the recording. “We just try to do the best possible research on all these cases.”

The episode carries a 2026 publication date but references no live tour dates remaining for the year, with 2027 dates expected to go on sale in early December through the show’s site, shutupandgivememurder.com.

Murphys case remains outline only in public feed

Neither the Apple Podcasts summary nor the podscripts.co transcript identifies the suspect, the victims, the dates of the deaths, or any court proceedings. The public description poses the central question — luck versus intent — without supplying investigative details, charging documents, or law‑enforcement statements.

California court records and Calaveras County Sheriff’s Office releases do not show a recent high‑profile double‑homicide prosecution in Murphys matching the podcast’s vague framing as of this writing. The hosts’ disclaimer that “the murder isn’t horrible and real because it is” signals the case is factual, yet no primary documents are cited in the released material.

Podcast business model frames true‑crime delivery

Small Town Murder operates on a freemium model: the main feed is free and ad‑supported, while a $5‑per‑month Patreon tier removes ads and adds bonus content, including a parallel “clown panic” episode teased for the same release week. The hosts also cross‑promote Crime in Sports and Your Stupid Opinions, broadening the network’s inventory for advertisers and subscribers.

Apple’s geographic restriction on the episode — listed for Africa, the Middle East, India, Latin America and the Caribbean — reflects platform‑level content‑rating controls rather than a legal hold on the case itself.

What remains unknown

No public charging document, coroner’s finding, or law‑enforcement press release has been linked to the podcast’s Murphys narrative. Until such records surface, the identity of the suspect, the cause and manner of the two deaths, and the status of any prosecution remain unverified in the public record.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.