International Edition
Latest News
Technology

South Dakotans Favor Pumpkin Pie and Potatoes

Pumpkin pie and potatoes rank as the top Thanksgiving dessert and side dish choices for South Dakotans, according to holiday search data analyzed by Only In Your State. The state's results emerged from holiday search data from across…

South Dakotans Favor Pumpkin Pie and Potatoes

Pumpkin pie and potatoes rank as the top Thanksgiving dessert and side dish choices for South Dakotans, according to holiday search data analyzed by Only In Your State.

The state’s results emerged from holiday search data from across the country examining every state’s Thanksgiving favorites. Pumpkin pie stands out as the top pie in 23 of the 51 places in the study, representing more than any other flavor. The dessert dates back to as early as 1672 and appears on most Thanksgiving tables across America.

While the country splits on side dishes, potatoes came out on top in 13 places, making them the second-most popular side in the study behind only the sweet potato group, which includes sweet potatoes, sweet potato casserole, and yams. South Dakota skips the sweet stuff on the side and saves it for the dessert plate.

South Dakotans Favor Pumpkin Pie and Potatoes
Photo: zippia.com

North Dakota and Montana share the exact pumpkin pie and potatoes pairing, creating identical favorite topping searches from Fargo to Billings. Arizona, Colorado, and Ohio complete the group of six states sharing this combination. Nationally, pumpkin pie and potatoes represent the second-most common pairing in the study, beaten only by pumpkin pie paired with sweet potatoes, sweet potato casserole, or yams.

Neighboring states show different preferences. Nebraska and Iowa both place pumpkin pie first, but Nebraska selects green bean casserole as its top side, while Iowa chooses corn casserole or corn pudding. Minnesota flips the pattern entirely, with potatoes winning the side-dish searches and cranberry pie taking the top dessert spot.

For those looking for dessert within the state, South Dakota features notable pie locations. In the Black Hills, Purple Pie Place located at 19 Mount Rushmore Road in Custer serves hundreds of slices of pie a week and includes a pet-friendly patio. Farther east, Leo’s Good Food in Redfield, a town of about 2,200 residents, is known for old-school homemade pies such as sour cream raisin and rhubarb custard.

The underlying findings are based on Google Trends search data collected by Only In Your State for 12 pies and 18 Thanksgiving side dishes, ranging from pumpkin and pecan pie to stuffing, gravy, and green bean casserole. The search parameters covered the United States for the month of November 2025, with closely related dishes grouped together.

About the author: Anika Shah - Technology

MSc in Computer Science, senior reporter. Anika focuses on AI ethics, cybersecurity, and emerging hardware—frequently moderating panels at CES and Web Summit. “Anika Shah decodes tech breakthroughs and startup disruption shaping tomorrow’s digital landscape.”