St. Paul Renters Face Ballot Measure on Repair Deductions
St. Paul voters are deciding a ballot measure that would allow tenants to deduct up to $500 or half a month’s rent for home repairs if their landlords fail to act. The proposed ordinance on the Nov. 3 ballot establishes a 14-day notice window for residents to address unmaintained properties before hiring outside help. Early voting is already underway across the city.
The policy targets residential properties where property owners neglect maintenance requests. Renters make up half of the capital city’s residents, according to the most recent U.S. Census survey. Proponents argue that existing legal avenues like rent escrow or court filings take too much time and money for everyday tenants. A similar ballot measure passed with nearly 70% of the vote in Duluth last year.
How the Proposed Right-to-Repair Ordinance Operates
Tenants utilizing the proposed Chapter 34A legislative code must provide a 14-day written notice to their landlords detailing required repairs. If property owners fail to correct the issue or schedule maintenance within that timeframe, renters can perform the work themselves or hire a contractor. Tenants then deduct those expenses from the following month’s rent while providing mandatory receipts.
The cost of work and materials cannot exceed $500 or one-half-month’s rent, whichever is greater. For government-subsidized housing, the deduction limit caps at half the apartment’s fair market rent rather than the tenant’s individual out-of-pocket payment. The ordinance covers 26 distinct categories of dwelling repairs.
Arguments From Campaign Supporters and Real Estate Opponents
Cole Hanson, coordinator for the Safe Homes Saint Paul coalition, states that the policy provides a common-sense resource for everyday tenants dealing with unresponsive landlords. Hanson notes that most landlords and tenants will never need to invoke the policy, which is designed strictly for edge cases where properties are ignored. Eleanor Berkenblit said she spent three cold months dealing with a faulty heating system before facing subsequent plumbing failures.
Conversely, business groups and property owners argue the measure harms housing development during a period of economic challenge. B Kyle, the St. Paul Area Chamber’s CEO, wrote in an op-ed that the ordinance would hinder growth and investment in the city’s tax base. Joe Abraham, who owns several hundred apartments in the Twin Cities through Pergola Management, calls the proposal a solution in search of a problem. Abraham points out that the state already maintains a court-supervised escrow process alongside newly established city administrative fines.
Legal Challenges and Housing Market Conditions
The St. Paul City Attorney’s Office challenged the ordinance’s enforceability before the Minnesota Court of Appeals, leaving a potential ruling pending while early votes are cast. Proponents maintain they have encountered no legal challenges regarding how identical rules function in Duluth.
The debate arrives five years after St. Paul voters approved rent control, a policy later modified by the City Council following economic pushback. An analysis by the Minnesota Reformer found that 88% fewer units were built in the city in 2024 compared to the previous three-year average. The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis stated in a recent St. Paul housing report that property owners feel “rent stabilization has had a profound effect on the market.”
Frequently Asked Questions About the St. Paul Ballot Measure
When is the election for the St. Paul repair measure?
The election takes place on Nov. 3, and early voting is currently underway across the city.
What is the maximum amount a renter can deduct?
Renters can deduct up to $500 or one-half-month’s rent—whichever is greater—provided they submit required receipts and have given a 14-day written notice.
How does this proposal compare to existing tenant laws?
While Minnesota already allows court-supervised rent escrow, proponents argue the new ordinance offers a faster, cheaper alternative to court filings.
Related reading