Stanford researchers found that genetic susceptibility determines how strongly saturated fat raises LDL cholesterol, based on an analysis of nearly 21,000 women in the Women’s Health Initiative published in JACC: Advances.
Women with the highest genetic risk scores saw significantly larger LDL increases from saturated fat than those with lower scores, and they also faced higher cardiovascular event rates when consuming more saturated fat, the study showed.
The findings help explain why two people can follow the same high-fat diet and get vastly different cholesterol results, said Shoa Clarke, a Stanford assistant professor of medicine and pediatrics who led the research.
“We have people who come into clinic and say, ‘I changed my diet and it made no difference in my cholesterol.’ Or they say, ‘I changed my diet and it had a huge effect on my cholesterol,'” Clarke told Stanford Medicine.
Researchers analyzed genetic data, dietary questionnaires, and cholesterol measurements from nearly 21,000 postmenopausal women enrolled in the Women’s Health Initiative, a long-term national health study.
Participants were divided into quartiles based on their genetic score. The team then examined the relationship between saturated fat intake and LDL cholesterol within each quartile, adjusting for age, total calories, and other dietary factors.
Divergent responses to saturated fat
In the top quartile of genetic risk, each 5% increase in calories from saturated fat was associated with an 11.2 mg/dL rise in LDL cholesterol. In the bottom quartile, the same dietary change corresponded to just a 2.8 mg/dL increase.
Cardiovascular event rates followed a similar pattern.
Women in the highest genetic-risk group who consumed the most saturated fat had a significantly higher risk of coronary heart disease events compared with those in the same genetic group who consumed the least. That association was not statistically significant in the lower three quartiles.
Authors caution findings are observational and limited to specific group
The results suggest that genetic profiling could eventually identify patients who would benefit most from saturated fat restriction, but the authors emphasized that the study was observational and limited to postmenopausal women of predominantly European ancestry.
“The effects of saturated fat may not be the same for everyone, but there isn’t any evidence of a cardiovascular benefit to eating more saturated fat,” Clarke said.
“The harms might vary from small to large depending on who you are.”
Current guidelines from the American Heart Association recommend limiting saturated fat to less than 6% of total daily calories for people who need to lower their cholesterol, and less than 10% for the general population.
What this means for patients
Clinicians say the findings reinforce the value of tracking individual bloodwork rather than relying on population averages or anecdotal diet success stories.
“If you’re making substantial dietary changes, ask when repeat cholesterol testing makes sense,” said preventive cardiologist Roger Blumenthal, director of the Johns Hopkins Ciccarone Center for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease, who was not involved in the study.
“Your bloodwork — not your buddy’s keto success story — should help guide the conversation.”
Genetic testing for dietary sensitivity is not currently recommended by major cardiology societies. The Stanford team plans to investigate whether the findings extend to men, younger adults, and more diverse populations.
Worth a look