Steelers’ QB Plans Shift: McShay Reveals Carson Beck as Target, Not Ty Simpson

The Pittsburgh Steelers’ search for a franchise quarterback continues to be a central focus as the 2026 NFL Draft approaches. Initial speculation heavily linked the team to Alabama’s Ty Simpson, but recent insights from NFL Draft analyst Todd McShay suggest a change in direction, with Miami’s Carson Beck emerging as a potential target.

Initial Interest in Ty Simpson Cools

Early in the draft process, Ty Simpson generated considerable buzz as a possible first-round selection for the Steelers. However, according to McShay, that sentiment has diminished. “It’s not Ty Simpson at 21, I can tell you that for a fact,” McShay stated on his podcast. Steelers Depot reports. Despite meeting with Simpson at the NFL Combine, the Steelers appear to be prioritizing other options.

Carson Beck Enters the Picture

McShay has indicated that the Steelers have been linked to Carson Beck, potentially as early as the first round, though he suggests a third-round selection might be a more realistic range. Beck, who played at the University of Miami in 2024 after five years at the University of Georgia, brings a different profile to the quarterback position.

Comparing Simpson and Beck

While Simpson is generally considered the second-best quarterback in the draft, his lack of experience is a concern. Beck, has accumulated nearly 1,400 pass attempts in college. However, Beck’s game is not without its weaknesses. A significant concern is his perceived lack of arm strength, which could hinder his success at the NFL level. He also doesn’t possess elite athleticism. Steelers Depot

McShay’s Assessment of Simpson’s Potential

Despite the Steelers seemingly moving away from Simpson, McShay has consistently praised the Alabama quarterback’s mental processing and command. He has even drawn comparisons to Joe Burrow, noting Simpson’s ability to “understand the inner workings of every play” and quickly identify pre-snap reads. SportsNet Pittsburgh reports McShay stating Simpson’s brain works “like a attractive mind” when processing information.

The Steelers’ Quarterback Dilemma

The Steelers’ quarterback situation remains a key question mark following their moves in free agency. With limited options available in free agency, the NFL Draft represents a crucial opportunity to address the position. The team’s interest in both Simpson and Beck highlights their exploration of various quarterback prospects, but McShay’s insights suggest a clear preference for Beck.

Looking Ahead

As the draft approaches, the Steelers will need to carefully evaluate their options and determine the best path forward at quarterback. While Beck may not possess the same upside as Simpson, his experience and familiarity with complex offensive schemes could craft him a more immediate contributor. The Steelers’ ultimate decision will likely depend on their assessment of each player’s potential and their overall draft strategy.