Average Hospital Charges Surge 182 Percent Across New York
Hospital mergers and consolidations across New York drove average patient charges up by more than 182 percent over a 15-year period, according to a study by the Community Service Society. That increase outpaced medical inflation by four times between 2009 and 2024. Half of the hospitals statewide participated in at least one merger during that timeframe.
Capital Region Consolidations Spark Monopoly Concerns
In the Capital Region, eight local hospitals underwent mergers between 2009 and 2024, leading to a highly concentrated market with near monopolies. St. Peter’s Health Partners and the Albany Med Health System acquired several local facilities during this period, while Albany Med Health System and Ellis Medicine have also contemplated a merger. Merged hospitals in the region increased patient charges 1.5 times faster than actual costs. Average charges grew by 26 percent to $28,360 nine years after a merger, while average costs rose just 17 percent to $11,520.
State Review Boards Lack Authority to Cap Post-Merger Prices
The New York State Department of Health oversees hospital mergers through its Public Health and Health Planning Council. The nonprofit’s study notes that New York hospitals have been undergoing a series of consolidations over the past 20 years, many of them encouraged by the state, including the Berger Commission in 2005, which recommended the closure, merging, or restructuring of dozens of statewide facilities. Danielle DeSouza, a spokeswoman for the state Department of Health, stated that the agency remains committed to keeping healthcare costs down while ensuring access to affordable care. However, the council lacks the legal authority to cap price increases at merged healthcare entities.
Unreleased Claims Database Conceals Regional Price Disparities
New York has spent more than $150 million developing the New York All-Payer Database authorized by the legislature in 2011, but the system remains unavailable to the public or researchers. Elisabeth Benjamin, president of health initiatives at the Community Service Society, criticized the delay. Mia Wagner, director of health policy at the organization, pointed to Maine’s public database, Compare Maine, as an effective model that allows consumers to compare exact facility charges for procedures like colonoscopies.
Legislative Proposals Target Universal Coverage and Fair Pricing
State Sen. Patricia Fahy sponsors two bills addressing healthcare affordability: the New York Health Act to create a universal healthcare system and the Fair Pricing Act to level outpatient versus hospital procedure pricing. Fahy called the current trajectory of healthcare costs unsustainable. Report authors suggest establishing strict state oversight, utilizing the dormant all-payer database to set regulatory guardrails during merger approvals, or reinstating state-set hospital rates last utilized before 1990s deregulation.
Common Medical Procedures Experience Post-Merger Price Spikes
Price increases following hospital consolidations affected routine medical procedures across all four state Department of Health regions. Patients undergoing appendectomies, vaginal childbirths, and knee replacements faced higher hospital charges regardless of procedure type. The report noted no evidence that cost savings achieved through consolidation transfer to patients or insurance payers. Rural communities and urban neighborhoods of color experienced the most severe disruptions due to post-merger unit closures and price hikes.
Frequently Asked Questions About New York Hospital Consolidations
How much faster did hospital charges grow compared to medical inflation?
Average hospital charges increased by more than 182 percent between 2009 and 2024, which is four times the rate of medical inflation at 44 percent during the same 15-year period.
What specific medical procedures were analyzed in the study?
The study examined appendectomies, vaginal childbirths, and knee replacements, finding post-merger price increases across all three categories in all four state Department of Health regions.
Why is the New York All-Payer Database unavailable?
Despite the state spending more than $150 million since the database was authorized in 2011 to collect healthcare payment data, state officials have not made the system accessible to the public or researchers.
Worth a look