People who view social hierarchies as natural skip grocery discounts and promotional codes more often than shoppers who expect equal treatment, according to marketing researchers who published their findings in the Journal of Marketing.
Social Hierarchies Shape Shopping Habits
Millions of households receive discount coupons, digital codes, and supermarket app promotions every week, yet only a small fraction of those offers are redeemed at checkout.
Researchers from the University of New Mexico, Indiana University, and the University of Manitoba examined this behavior across eight separate investigations. They determined that the hesitation to use coupons stems not from forgetfulness or laziness, but from an individual’s view on power distribution in society.
Psychologists and culture researchers call this perspective power distance belief. It measures how readily a person accepts that status, power, and resources are unevenly divided among people. Individuals with high power distance view authorities, corporate entities, and bosses as natural figures positioned above them. Those with low power distance prioritize equality and decision-making on equal footing.
In field trials conducted at local cafés and grocery stores, participants who held higher power distance let their coupons expire more frequently. They described the promotional offers as manipulative tactics designed primarily for corporate advantage. The research team observed this identical pattern in scanner-panel purchase data.
Skepticism Behind Unused Disounts
Unlike a standard price drop, a coupon represents a deliberate corporate gesture that prompts consumers to question underlying motives. Skeptical shoppers view a price reduction not as an authentic savings opportunity, but as a maneuver to clear out inferior inventory, disguise inflated base prices, or encourage unnecessary spending.
“When you give discounts, some people immediately ask if something is wrong with the product or if the price was raised beforehand,” said Sijie Sun from the University of Manitoba.
Conversely, shoppers with low power distance tend to assume a fair relationship exists between buyer and seller. They accept coupons at face value as genuine price reductions rather than hidden tricks.
Previous Research on Price Sensitivity
The findings build on earlier studies examining how power distance influences financial decisions. Ashok Lalwani and Lura Forcum published a study in the Journal of Consumer Research on May 5, 2016, detailing how power distance beliefs alter judgments regarding price and quality relationships.
A subsequent paper published in the Journal of Marketing in 2020 by Lalwani, Hyejin Lee, and Jessie J. Wang demonstrated that high power distance consumers display lower price sensitivity. Those shoppers exhibit a stronger need for quick, final decisions, prompting them to grab the first available offer instead of hunting for lower prices.
Regional Differences in Coupon Redemptions
The research team measured power distance across individual United States regions. Southern states tend to exhibit high power distance, whereas regions like New York and California show lower scores where equality receives greater emphasis.
Retailers relying heavily on coupon promotions achieve higher success rates in areas with low power distance. Because direct surveys regarding societal hierarchies are difficult to conduct, the study suggests using regional political alignment as a reliable proxy, given that conservative areas generally register higher power distance scores than progressive regions.
Strategies to Reduce Consumer Skepticism
Retailers can mitigate customer mistrust by explaining why a discount is offered and addressing potential doubts directly. The experiments demonstrated that a price guarantee—where a store promises to match lower prices found elsewhere—effectively eliminates the gap in coupon usage between high and low power distance consumers.
Stores can also design shopping environments that encourage independent decision-making. Highlighting that customers can freely compare prices and make autonomous choices helps foster a balanced dynamic at the point of sale.
Researchers Analyzed Eight Primary Investigations
What specific data sources did the researchers analyze?
The study analyzed eight primary investigations that included field experiments at local retail shops, evaluations of scanner-panel purchasing data, and participant surveys assessing societal hierarchy attitudes.
How does political orientation relate to power distance beliefs?
In the United States, conservative regions tend to display higher power distance scores, while progressive regions emphasize social equality and record lower scores.
Established in 1936, the Journal of Marketing is a bimonthly peer-reviewed publication issued by the American Marketing Association. Serving as a premier outlet for substantive marketing scholarship, the publication develops and disseminates knowledge regarding real-world marketing questions for scholars, educators, managers, policy makers, and consumers. Since its founding, the publication has played a significant role in shaping the content and boundaries of the marketing discipline.
What retail strategy effectively bridges the redemption gap?
Implementing a price guarantee where a store matches lower prices found elsewhere successfully equalizes coupon redemption rates across different consumer hierarchy beliefs.