The former Sunset Restaurant at 180 St. Paul St. has reopened under new ownership that chose to refurbish the 70-year-old diner rather than demolish it, St. Catharines Standard reported.
Longtime owners John and Koula Macris sold the business to retire, and the property later listed for sale again with the interior largely unchanged for decades. New owners Zach and his team, who also operate two downtown restaurants, opted to preserve the brick exterior, yellow-and-red signage — including the “Air Conditioned” sign — and the original tile mosaic uncovered beneath layers of wood, St. Catharines Standard reported.
They worked with interior designer Westgrove to add mirrors, lighting, seating and reupholstered booths while keeping most of the existing millwork, according to St. Catharines Standard. The menu centers on steak-and-cheese sandwiches, chili cheese dogs, chili cheese fries, pizza steak sandwiches and cheesecake with lemon curd.
“They wanted to preserve an iconic diner and build something different from their two downtown restaurants: a casual spot where you can grab a meal and spend time somewhere that feels familiar,” St. Catharines Standard reported, paraphrasing the ownership group.
Welland Tribune and Niagara Falls Review each published matching accounts under the headline “New life breathed into former Sunset Restaurant,” confirming the sale, the preservation-focused renovation and the comfort-food menu direction.

The project emphasized repair over replacement. Crews uncovered a tile mosaic hidden under wood flooring, restored original millwork and added new decor elements rather than gutting the space, St. Catharines Standard reported. The iconic exterior signage, including the vintage “Air Conditioned” lettering, remains in place.
The opening menu features the Original Philly with Whiz Wit Blend at $26 and the Shawarma Chicken and Cheese at $23, according to St. Catharines Standard. A Szechuan Chicken sandwich on Texas toast with sesame slaw and garlic mayo is listed at $16. Chili cheese dogs, chili cheese fries, pizza steak sandwiches and cheesecake with lemon curd round out the comfort-food lineup.
The new operators also run two downtown St. Catharines restaurants, St. Catharines Standard reported. They described the Sunset project as a deliberate departure from those venues, aiming for a neighborhood diner atmosphere rather than a downtown dining concept.
180 St. Paul St. in St. Catharines, Ontario.
The ownership group is led by Zach, who also operates two downtown St. Catharines restaurants, St. Catharines Standard reported.
John and Koula Macris sold the business to retire, according to St. Catharines Standard.
The Original Philly with Whiz Wit Blend ($26) and the Shawarma Chicken and Cheese ($23) are highlighted, along with a Szechuan Chicken sandwich ($16), chili cheese dogs, chili cheese fries, pizza steak sandwiches and cheesecake with lemon curd, St. Catharines Standard reported.
Sunset Restaurant opened 70 years ago at 180 St. Paul St. and served breakfast to locals for more than six decades, becoming one of the few Niagara establishments to keep its original feel intact. Its brick exterior and classic yellow signs with red lettering, including the vintage “Air Conditioned” lettering, made the diner a recognizable landmark on St. Paul Street.
No. The new owners chose to refurbish the existing structure, preserving the brick exterior, vintage signage, original millwork and a hidden tile mosaic, St. Catharines Standard reported.
Keep reading