International Edition
Latest News
News

Supreme Court Annuls Lower Court Rulings in Sailor’s Injury Case Against Foreign Employer

Ukrainian courts cannot hear claims against foreign employers until they first establish international jurisdiction, the Supreme Court ruled on September 16 in a case involving a sailor injured on a Latvian-flagged vessel in the Indian Ocean. The Malinovsky…

Sailor lost a hand due to a cable break during crab fishing, but instead of 9 million UAH compensation received a legal

Ukrainian courts cannot hear claims against foreign employers until they first establish international jurisdiction, the Supreme Court ruled on September 16 in a case involving a sailor injured on a Latvian-flagged vessel in the Indian Ocean.

The Malinovsky District Court of Odesa and the Odesa Court of Appeal had dismissed the sailor’s lawsuit over conflicting citizenship documents and an alleged misidentification of the employer. The Supreme Court annulled both decisions, case No. 521/21513/23, and ordered a new trial, Judicial and Legal Newspaper reported.

“Establishing the content of foreign law norms applicable to legal relations with a foreign element is the court’s duty and is carried out ex officio,” the Supreme Court wrote in its ruling. “Failure by a party to provide documents confirming the content of foreign law is not grounds for automatic refusal of the claim.”

The plaintiff, a Ukrainian citizen, said he signed an employment contract on June 25, 2018 with a Latvian shipowner. On September 6, 2018, while crab fishing in the Indian Ocean, a 100-kilogram steel grab struck his right hand when a stopper cable snapped, throwing him overboard. Surgeons in Maputo, Mozambique amputated the hand. He was later assigned permanent disability group III and said he could no longer work as a sailor.

He sued in September 2023 seeking roughly 100,300 dollars for health damage as of August 5, 2023, 61,200 dollars for three years of future compensation, monthly payments of 1,700 dollars thereafter, 75,795.52 euros for prosthetics, and 20,000 dollars for moral damages. The district court refused the claim on March 18, 2025, citing a discrepancy: the employment contract and accident reports listed the sailor as a Moldovan citizen. The appellate court upheld the refusal in January 2026 but shifted the rationale, ruling the plaintiff had sued the wrong defendant and that neither side proved whether he was insured or received insurance payments. The Supreme Court found both lower courts skipped the threshold question.

Under Article 8 of Ukraine’s Law on Private International Law, the court must determine ex officio whether Ukrainian jurisdiction extends to the dispute, considering Articles 76 and 77 of that law and Articles 20, 34 and 42 of the treaty on legal assistance between Ukraine and Latvia.

The courts also failed to establish which country’s substantive law governs the employment relationship and did not properly assess the contract and accident report to confirm the plaintiff’s status as the defendant’s employee. The case returns to the court of first instance for a new trial.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.