President Donald Trump faces anger from ranchers over a push to allow more foreign beef into the U.S., but the country was already importing record amounts as domestic cattle numbers hit a 75-year low and farms consolidated.
National cattle numbers fell from about 95 million in 2019 to an estimated 86 million, according to U.S. Department of Agriculture data cited by South Dakota Searchlight. Meanwhile, the number of U.S. farms and ranches with cattle dropped from over a million in the 1970s to about 600,000.
Trump Proclamation Temporarily Increases Lean Beef Imports
In August, President Trump signed a proclamation to temporarily increase beef supplies by importing 300,000 metric tons—or 661 million pounds—of lean beef trimmings at a reduced tariff rate over a 90-day period from September through November, Fortune reported. Trump said that the deal would lower grocery costs while giving the American beef herd room to grow.
“This deal will reduce prices for Americans while giving space for our Great American Beef Herd to grow again,” Trump wrote on Truth Social announcing the policy, according to Fortune. However, U.S. Customs and Border Protection data showed that the country had imported just 59,423 metric tons as of Oct. 19, reaching only 20% of the target, according to Fortune.
Ground beef averaged $6.79 per pound in September, down slightly from $6.92 in August but still above the $6.32 recorded a year earlier, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data cited by Fortune. Agricultural economists said that the imported lean trimmings typically go to fast-food restaurants rather than grocery store shelves, meaning the influx does not directly address retail costs.
“Unfortunately, the beef industry is much more complex than that.” “When you take away the tariff, you make it cheaper, but you don’t necessarily increase the demand because we only need so much of it,” Peel said. “We were getting as much as we wanted.”

The policy announcement also rattled domestic markets. Scott Kolousek, a farmer and rancher from Wessington Springs, said the news sent cattle futures lower. A $10-per-hundredweight drop reduces an 800-pound calf’s value by $80, which can mean a $16,000 loss for a producer selling 200 calves, South Dakota Searchlight reported. “For a producer selling 200 calves, that’s a $16,000 difference that “you can lose in a matter of minutes,” Kolousek said.
“When this news comes out of Washington, the markets are up and down, up and down,” Kolousek told South Dakota Searchlight.
Brett Kenzy, a rancher from Gregory, said abrupt import changes undermine the long-term planning required to raise cattle, which involves years of raising heifers and waiting for calves to reach market weight.
“What’s required to build our cattle herd up is confidence — confidence in the market, and we don’t have that right now,” Kenzy told South Dakota Searchlight.
“He is delivering on his promise to consumers by reducing beef prices while allowing our American beef herd to grow,” White House spokesperson Anna Kelly told Fortune in a statement. “The President will continue taking actions to support our great farmers while driving economic prosperity for all Americans.”
Proposal Adds Insurance for Retained Heifers and Disaster Aid
The proposal includes a two-year insurance option to protect ranchers who retain young heifers for breeding rather than sending them to slaughter, alongside disaster recovery assistance on federally protected grasslands.

Lawmakers are also pursuing Mandatory Country of Origin Labeling. The U.S. Senate Agriculture Committee approved an amendment from Majority Leader John Thune in August to reinstate labeling in the pending farm bill, which advanced out of committee in September, News From The States reported.
Beyond federal policies, producers pointed to heavy market concentration as a barrier to recovery. The industry has spent decades becoming more concentrated in cattle feeding and meatpacking, and “we’ve lost a huge number of independent packing plants and feeders in this country,” South Dakota Searchlight reported.
That’s meant more producers have to take whatever’s offered. While the Department of Justice investigates potential anticompetitive practices, Kenzy argued that herd building cannot succeed without a long-term fair price mechanism.
Related reading