An Uber driver’s decision to drop two passengers on a Southern California freeway in August 2023 resulted in a $40 million settlement for the family of 23-year-old Emily Normandin-Parker, who was struck and killed by a vehicle while searching for help.
The fatal incident occurred after the driver, Vu Tran, swerved between lanes and subsequently ordered the women out of his car on a triangular stretch of pavement between the highway and an exit ramp.
While Normandin-Parker’s friend, Luna Moore, remained at the scene to address the driver’s demand for a $300 cleaning fee, Normandin-Parker walked into traffic. Moore, who was later awarded $300,000 in civil arbitration, told The Post that Tran physically blocked her from following her friend.
Questioning of Personal History
Moore told The Post that she was subjected to a nine-hour deposition involving invasive questions about her childhood medical history, past experiences with sexual abuse, and the specific clothing she wore on the night of the incident.
“They spent three years trying to convince me that Emily died because I drank too much,” Moore told The Post. While Uber said that lawyers independently retained by the driver were responsible for the questioning, a deposition transcript reviewed by The Post shows that attorneys for the company also questioned Moore regarding her mental health and her use of prescription medication.

Legal Tactics in Litigation
Attorneys representing plaintiffs in other injury and wrongful-death cases against Uber allege that such discovery tactics are part of a broader strategy. According to California attorney Brooke Soliz Bremmer, the company often requests extensive medical and psychiatric records even in cases where the passenger was not the driver.
“If you’re demanding a woman’s therapy records all the way back to childhood, that isn’t discovery. It’s absolute intimidation,” Bremmer told The Post. Attorney Alex Boris added that these sweeping demands for records often lack time limits, which forces plaintiffs’ legal teams to expend significant time and resources fighting the requests.
Defense of Litigation Practices
Uber maintains that its legal strategy is necessary to address the validity of claims. Katie Waitzman, Uber’s chief deputy general counsel, told The Post that the company has a responsibility to defend itself through a process that examines evidence on both sides.
“When Uber is asked to compensate someone for an injury or loss, we are entitled to examine evidence about what caused it and the damages attributable to it,” Waitzman told The Post. The company also said that it expressed sympathy to the Normandin-Parker family, though it maintained that the arbitrator’s decision to hold the company legally responsible for the death was incorrect.
Legal Scrutiny of Discovery
The scope of Uber’s discovery demands has faced pushback from the judiciary. U.S. Magistrate Judge Lisa Cisneros ruled that the company’s requests for medical and family history documentation in sexual assault litigation were overly broad. Similar restrictions were placed on the company’s access to social media records the following month.
Legal experts suggest that such wide-ranging discovery can become a “fishing expedition” that puts an undue burden on plaintiffs. “It seems like a strategic way to impose cost, to impose burden, to take advantage of the fact that a lot of these victims are not going to know what’s permissible discovery and what’s not,” Maria Glover, a Georgetown University law professor, told The Post.
Questions Answered About Settlement Confidentiality and Driver Outcome
- Did Uber successfully keep the $40 million settlement confidential?
No. Even after the $40 million arbitration award was handed down, Emily’s parents said Uber sought to keep the outcome under wraps. - How does Uber justify requests for childhood medical records?
Uber maintains that it is standard practice to examine medical history to determine which injuries or damages are directly attributable to the specific incident being litigated, rather than pre-existing conditions. - What was the outcome for the driver involved?
The legal claims were handled through a civil arbitration process that resulted in a $40 million award for the family of the deceased and a $300,000 award for Moore.