The leaders of the United States, China and Russia met for the first time as a trio in Shenzhen on Thursday, producing a joint declaration but no breakthroughs on the wars dividing them.
The meeting placed Chinese President Xi Jinping at the center of a round table flanked by U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin, a seating arrangement that highlighted Beijing’s role as convener. The session lasted more than an hour, according to the White House.
“Each gained prestige while giving up little policy ground,” said Craig Singleton, senior fellow and director of the China Program at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies.
By meeting Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin is sending a holiday postcard to the rest of the world. But instead of ‘Wish you were here’, he’s signed it ‘Look: I’m here.’ My report from Shenzhen. https://t.co/K3SfGT57fN
Declaration covers UN reform, nuclear pledge and ICC criticism
The three leaders issued a statement pledging to reform the United Nations, ensure stable refined-oil supplies, oppose what they called abuses of jurisdiction by the International Criminal Court and affirm that a nuclear war “cannot be won and must never be fought,” Al Jazeera reported.
Critics called the text the lowest common denominator.
President Trump departs China after a historic trip. – Secured $17 billion for U. S. companies. – Met with the world's most important leaders and nations, including President Xi, President Putin, and President Marcos. – Delivered key remarks at both the ASEAN and APEC Summits.… pic.twitter.com/YVqOqnABEY
Putin returns to top table despite ICC warrant
The summit marked Putin’s first appearance at a major multilateral gathering since the ICC issued an arrest warrant for him in 2023 over alleged war crimes in Ukraine. The Russian leader was “reportedly in a brilliant mood,” a Kremlin aide told Russian state media.
Trump praised Putin publicly, calling him “my friend” and telling European nations they could save money and lives by ending the war with Russia, according to Politico.
A historic first on the world stage. President Donald J. Trump, President Xi, and President Putin hold trilateral talks in China. pic.twitter.com/w2qDiJo8W5
Trump emphasizes personal ties over policy detail
At a White House briefing Friday, Trump defended his closeness with Putin and Xi, saying the relationships keep the United States safe. Asked by CNN’s Kaitlan Collins whether Putin is a friend to America, Trump replied, “I can’t speak to America.”
He described the war in Ukraine as a “public relations war” driven by “tremendous hatred” between Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, and suggested Russia’s invasion “should have lasted one day.”
Secretary of State Marco Rubio offered a more structured defense. “The better these three leaders get along, the easier and more conducive the environment will be to actually agree to things that are concrete down the road,” Rubio said.
Analysts compare optics to Yalta, find substance lacking
Before the meeting, commentators asked whether it would become a “Yalta 2.0” — a reference to the 1945 conference where three powers divided postwar Europe. Putin paused and nodded when a reporter put the question to him; Xi urged the three countries to abandon “Cold War thinking,” Al Jazeera reported.
Great piece by @AsiaLens @leahyjoseph @WillLangley96 on China's strengthened position coming out of APEC in Shenzhen—the climax of an exceptionally ambitious year of diplomacy from Xi Jinping: For Xi, the summit marked the high point of a year in which he has brought Trump, his…
China declines trilateral nuclear framework
Washington has long sought a trilateral arms-control framework including Russia and China. Beijing has refused to join on equal terms, citing its estimated 620 warheads against roughly 5,000 each for the United States and Russia, Al Jazeera reported.
Chinese officials have also posed a counterfactual on Ukraine: had China chosen to arm Russia, the front would not look as it does today.
White House ruled out Ukraine discussion at APEC
The meeting occurred Thursday in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the APEC summit.
No. The White House said beforehand Ukraine would not be discussed, and the declaration omitted the war entirely.
Chosen for its proximity to Hong Kong, the city has since grown to a population of 18.2 million and a GDP that has surpassed Hong Kong and Singapore, making it one of the world’s ten largest urban economies and home to the Shenzhen Stock Exchange and technology giants such as Huawei and Tencent.
Beijing has refused to join a framework on equal terms, citing its far smaller arsenal compared with the United States and Russia.
More on Russia
🇨🇳🇷🇺🇺🇦🇺On November 19, President Xi Jinping held the #China-#Russia-#US Summit with President Vladimir Putin and President Donald J. Trump in #Shenzhen. Chinese FM Spokesperson: The China-Russia-U. S. Shenzhen Summit will be the first ever face-to-face meeting between the… pic.twitter.com/3UGMCS26WX
Related reading