International Edition
Latest News
World

US, Russia and China Set to Block Global Ban on Autonomous Weapons at UN Conference

The United States, Russia, and China look set to block negotiations on a global ban for lethal autonomous weapons at a United Nations conference in Geneva this week. More than 70 countries are ready to start talks on…

US, Russia and China Set to Block Global Ban on Autonomous Weapons at UN Conference

The United States, Russia, and China look set to block negotiations on a global ban for lethal autonomous weapons at a United Nations conference in Geneva this week.

More than 70 countries are ready to start talks on prohibiting artificial intelligence weapons, New Scientist reported. Major military powers are expected to obstruct these efforts during the seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons.

The UN treaty binds 128 states together to regulate harmful weapons, but the meeting operates on unanimity, meaning a single state can block action. The US proposed investigating how existing international law applies to autonomous weapons instead, effectively delaying potential bans until a future meeting in 2031, according to New Scientist.

Artificial intelligence is increasingly common in modern conflict to sort intelligence and steer weapons. A senior Ukrainian defense industry figure told New Scientist earlier this year that a test took place two years ago involving fully autonomous drones that killed two enemy soldiers without human oversight.

“Machines shouldn’t make life and death decisions. Tasking weapons systems or algorithms to identify targets and kill people is just a moral red line we shouldn’t be crossing,” said Elizabeth Minor at pressure group Stop Killer Robots, speaking to New Scientist.

US, Russia and China Set to Block Global Ban on Autonomous Weapons at UN Conference
Photo: theguardian.com

“What we'll obviously see as the week goes on, unfortunately, is the weakening of this text [from Peru] at the behest of larger militarised states who want to continue to see these weapons unregulated,” said Elizabeth Minor at pressure group Stop Killer Robots, speaking to New Scientist.

Global Division Over Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems

Peru, as chair of the conference, proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol. Minor told New Scientist that 130 countries support a ban or restrictions, with over 70 ready to begin formal negotiations. However, nations including the UK, Japan, and South Korea are likely to align with major powers to weaken the text.

Reuters reported that Russia stymied early talks by objecting to procedural rules allowing observers and non-governmental organizations to speak. Ireland and Canada opposed the Russian objection. The International Committee of the Red Cross warned that the world cannot afford further delays in regulating these systems.

“The time has come to move from discussion to negotiation on new international rules to regulate autonomous systems. The world cannot afford further delays,” the International Committee of the Red Cross stated.

Meanwhile, nations operating fast-reacting defensive systems, such as ship-protection missiles, resist broad prohibitions. Aurel Sari at the University of Exeter explained that a wide ban risks catching defensive systems, while a narrow ban might achieve little.

US, Russia and China Set to Block Global Ban on Autonomous Weapons at UN Conference
Photo: usnews.com

“None of the major powers wants an agreement that would hand its rivals an advantage on the battlefield,” Sari said.

Diplomatic Impasse and Future Negotiations

A coalition of 50 states, including Ireland, France, Germany, and Brazil, pushed for a strict negotiating mandate involving three sessions in Geneva totaling 25 days through 2027. The US favors non-binding guidelines, arguing that existing international humanitarian law provides an adequate framework.

Pope Leo XIV also intervened in the debate, stating that AI weapons must be disarmed. “Decisions affecting human life, freedom and the use of force must always remain subject to effective, informed and responsible human oversight,” Pope Leo XIV said, as reported by theguardian.com.

Stop Killer Robots, launched in April 2013 as a coalition of non-governmental organizations including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, has pressed governments and the United Nations to pre-emptively ban lethal autonomous weapons systems.

In July 2015, more than 1,000 artificial intelligence experts signed an open letter at the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Buenos Aires warning of a military AI arms race and calling for a ban; co-signatories included Stephen Hawking, Elon Musk and Google DeepMind co-founder Demis Hassabis. By 2023, over 70 states had called for new international law on these weapons, with more than 30 explicitly supporting a legally binding prohibition.

Deliberations are closed to the public, with an announcement expected on November 21. Campaigners suggest supporters might bypass the CCW entirely and take the issue to the UN General Assembly, where a simple majority can authorize treaty negotiations.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.