United States crypto regulation hit a wall on September 15 when the Senate fell short of the majority needed to end debate on the CLARITY Act, failing by a vote of 49 to 50, according to the US-Senat.
Democratic negotiators blocked the legislation due to unresolved ethics questions surrounding Donald Trump’s crypto holdings. Former CFTC Chairman Christopher Giancarlo told Cointelegraph at the SALT London conference that he was “pretty glad” the bill failed, calling it overly complicated.
Giancarlo argued that the Internet and artificial intelligence emerged without dedicated authorization acts, suggesting that writing rules before technology is “kind of a European thing.” He maintained that the United States retains its lead in global crypto due to its financial markets and tech talent.
The failure of the CLARITY Act shows how personal political assets continue to stall legislative progress in Washington. Giancarlo acknowledged that Trump-adjacent memecoins and personal crypto dealings fueled opposition from lawmakers.
The primary motivation for the crypto industry to seek legislation was preventing a return of hostility from the Biden administration, Giancarlo said. He praised the appointment of crypto-friendly regulators at the SEC, CFTC, and OCC despite the legislative setback.
With the legislative path blocked, regulatory agencies are preparing to act independently. SEC Chairman Paul Atkins stated in September that the commission will move decisively “with or without statutory regulation” within its existing statutory powers.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said his agency is “firmly committed and ready to get its rules for the new financial world on track.”
The SEC previously proposed registration exceptions and a conditional safe harbor for tokens under “Regulation Crypto Assets” in August, according to Finanzen.
Bernstein analysts expected an aggressive and swift rulemaking process following the Senate vote, noting that stablecoins remain unaffected as they are governed by the GENIUS Act.
Charley Cooper, a former CFTC chief of staff now at Ava Labs, estimated that finalized rules could take more than six months to materialize.
The defeat of the CLARITY Act shifts the immediate focus for crypto investors and exchanges from Congress to federal regulators. While current leaders at the SEC and CFTC offer friendly registration exceptions, those rules lack permanent legislative protection.
Atkins previously warned that only a statute is indispensable for permanent rules, as a future administration can rescind agency regulations. If Cooper’s timeline holds, finalized rules may not appear before spring 2027, leaving regulatory certainty tied directly to the political calendar and the 2028 presidential election.